University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses

Reflections on contemporary art and the rhetoric of community

(USC Thesis Other)

Reflections on contemporary art and the rhetoric of community

PDF

Download a page range

Download transcript

Copy asset link

Request this asset

Transcript (if available)

Content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`7!$DAA>!:;@!1:6<E6!/:;<`7!+6>867!AF!CED;6>:3D6!.>>:;<6G6;?7! AM6>:?6!A;!:!GA>6!:37?>:9?!D6P6D!:;@!6GMDA4!:>?87?89!7?>:?6<867!?=:?!@A!;A?! ;69677:>8D4!8;PADP6!M:>?898M:;?7!?A!>6@8>69?!;A>G:?8P6!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4! ?AR:>@7!:;!:D?A<6?=6>!@8FF6>6;?!GA@6D!AF!9ADD69?8P8?4!:;@!7E3_69?8P8?4S!A;6!?=:?! @>:R7!EMA;!=6?6>A<6;68?4!>:?=6>!?=:;!A;!:!E?AM89!8@6:DT! ! ! ! ! ! ! L! (*'")02&'()*! ! (!36<8;!R8?=!?=6!HE67?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!(?!87!:3D6!?A!:??>:9?S!:9?8P:?6!:;@! GA38D8a6!?=6!6;6><867!AF!?=6!GA7?!@8P6>76!<>AEM7!AF!M6AMD6T!1AR!@A67!A;6!E;>:P6D! 9AGGE;8?4`7!8;=6>6;?!FA>96b!N=6>6!@A67!A;6!36<8;!?A!3DE6M>8;?!8?7!@6F8;8?8A;b!(7! ?=6>6!:!747?6G:?89!:MM>A:9=!?A!6Q:G8;6!?=6!:MM6:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!8@6;?8F4!8?7! P:>8AE7!<E8767!:;@!FA>G:?8A;7S!:;@!@6?:9=!8?!F>AG!8?7!8@6ADA<89:D!M>67?8<6!8;!A>@6>!?A! @6P6DAM!:!GA>6!7AD8@!G:7?6>4!AP6>!AE>!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!!c9AGGE;8?4bd!! %8;@:!+8;<6>!R>8?67S!c&AGGE;8?4!9:;!36!AFF6>6@!:7!:;!A3_69?!AF!:MM6:76G6;?! A>!8;98?6G6;?S!:7M8>:?8A;!A>!:99AGMD87=G6;?e?=6!6D:7?898?4!AF!9AGGE;8?4Sd!7=6! 9A;?8;E67S!c87!8?7!:MM6:DS!:;!:MM6:D!?=:?!AM6>:?67!;A?!:7!M>676;96!3E?!:7!@879AE>76S! 6Q9=:;<6S!:;@!@8FF6>6;96Td L !! '=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4!87!:!P6>4!7D8MM6>4!RA>@S!@66MD4!>AA?6@!R8?=!:;! 6DE78P6;677!?=:?!G:U67!8?!PED;6>:3D6!?A!P:>8AE7!E767!:;@!G87E767!8;!@8FF6>6;?! 9A;@8?8A;7!:;@!9A;?6Q?7T!'=6!@8FF6>6;?!@6F8;8?8A;7!?=:?!7E>>AE;@!8?!766G!?A!;A?!A;D4! 9AGMD89:?6!8?7!DA<89S!3E?!:D7A!<6;6>:?6!:;!:GA>M=AE7!76?!AF!9A;7?>:8;?7!:;@!?6;6?7! ?=:?!7AG6=AR!87!:3D6!?A!:9?!:7!:;!A><:;8a8;<!M>8;98MD6!FA>!9ADD69?8P6!8@6;?8?4T!!(;! A>@6>!?A!36<8;!:!@879E778A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!8?!G:4!36!M>A@E9?8P6!?A!6Q:G8;6!?=6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! L !%8;@:!+8;<6>!78?E:?67!:!@879E778A;!:3AE?!9AGGE;8?4!8;!:!9A;?6GMA>:>4!A>! cMA7?GA@6>;d!9A;?6Q?!9>8?89:DD4!6Q:G8;8;<!?=6!9AGMD6Q8?867S!9AGM>AG8767S!:;@! MA77838D8?867!8;PADP6@!8;!:!>6P878A;87?!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:?!368;<!c:?!DAA76! 6;@7Td!+66V!%8;@:!+8;<6>S!c"69:DD8;<!:!&AGGE;8?4!:?!%AA76!#;@7Sd!8;!@#&&0*+5<-15- A##,'-B*>,S!6@T!'=6!,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V!2;8P6>78?4!AF! ,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!LJ]T! ! J! P:>8AE7!8GMD6G6;?:?8A;7!AF!?=6!RA>@!9AGGE;8?4T!'=87!87!6Q:9?D4!R=:?!R>8?6>!%:>7! (46>!@A67!8;!:!@6;76!M:77:<6V!! $A>!?=6!D6F?S!9AGGE;8?4!:9?8P87G!G8<=?!M6>G8?!:!<>:77>AA?7!>6P8P:D!AF!MAMED:>! 7EMMA>?i!FA>!?=6!>8<=?S!?=6!>6?E>;!AF!G:;:<6>8:D!>67MA;7838D8?4!?A!?=6! 9AGGE;8?4!94;89:DD4!G:7U7!?=6!@87G:;?D8;<!AF!?=6!R6DF:>6!7?:?6T!$A>!<:47S! 3D:9U7S!:;@!F6G8;87?7S!?=6!:MM6:D!AF!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:FF8>G7!:! >6787?:;96!?A!F:D76!8;9DE78A;!:;@!?A!?=6!6>:7E>6!AF!7M698F89!@8FF6>6;967i!FA>! MAD8?898:;7!766U8;<!>6\6D69?8A;S!?=6!@678>6!?A!M>A@E96!:!76;76!AF!9ADD69?8P6! :FF8D8:?8A;!87!6QM>6776@!8;!?=6!:MM6:D!FA>!:DD!?A!>69A<;8a6!?=6G76DP67!:7! G6G36>7!AF!:!<6;6>:D!9AGGE;8?4T J !!! ! (;!9A;?6GMA>:>4!:>?S!?=6!>=6?A>89!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!:D7A!P6>4!GE9=!6;<:<6@!8;! :!78G8D:>!78?E:?8A;!R=6>6!?=6!:MM:>6;?!E76!:;@!:3E76!AF!?=6!FDE8@S!:;@!M6>=:M7! E;7?:3D6S!HE:D8?4!AF!9AGGE;8?4!G:?6>8:D8a67T!'=6>6!=:7!366;!:!M>A;AE;96@!7=8F?!8;! ?=6!?AMA<>:M=4!AF!9A;?6GMA>:>4!:>?!R8?=!?=6!>876!AF!M:>?898M:?A>4!:;@!9AGGE;8?4\ 3:76@!M>A_69?7T!!->A_69?7!D8U6!?=6!76G8;:D!@0"50$'-+*-385+#*!9E>:?6@!34!,:>4!5:;6! 5:9A37!8;!L[[J\L[[Y!:@@>677!7M698F89!9AGGE;8?867!>:;<8;<!F>AG!P:>8AE7!G8;A>8?4! <>AEM7!?A!6P6;!?=6!:>?!ME3D89!8?76DFT!!(;!@A8;<!7AS!?=64!9A;7?:;?D4!7AD898?!?=6!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4T!!! '=6!;A>G:?8P6!@6F8;8?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!E;@6>7?AA@!:7!:!9ADD69?8P6!3A@4! ?=:?!G6@8:?67!36?R66;!8;@8P8@E:D!7E3_69?7!:;@!?=6!D:><6>!7A986?4T!!'=6!8;=6>6;?! :G38<E8?4!AF!?=6!?6>G!87!:!@87?8;9?8P6!?>:8?!?=:?!ED?8G:?6D4!M>A3D6G:?8a67!8;@8P8@E:D! 7E3_69?8P8?4!:;@!7A98:D!>6D:?8A;7T!!'>:@8?8A;:D!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!>6PADP6!:>AE;@! FA>G7!AF!8@6;?8?4!?=:?!E7E:DD4!76>P6!68?=6>!MA78?8P6!A>!;6<:?8P6!FE;9?8A;7T!!);!A;6! =:;@S!9AGGE;8?4!6;9AE>:<67!E7!?A!7E7?:8;!:!7=:>6@!9A;798AE7;677!7=:M6@!34! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! J !%:>7!(46>S!c)E>!"67MA;7838D8?4V!ID:;9=A?`7!&AGGE;87GSd!@#*5$'&C,-D!f,:4!JKKLhS! =??MVggRRRTE74@T6@ET:Eg9A;?>6GM7gJG:4JKKLg846>TM@F!f:996776@!LJ!,:>9=! JKLKhS!^LT! ! Y! 9AGGA;!6QM6>86;967!A>!8;?6>67?7T!!);!?=6!A?=6>!=:;@S!9ADD69?8P6!8@6;?8?4!9:;!:D7A!36! 67?:3D87=6@!34!:;!A><:;8a8;<!M>8;98MD6!?=:?!@A67!:7!GE9=!?A!>6M>677!7M698F89! @8FF6>6;967!:7!8?!@A67!?A!96D63>:?6!MA8;?7!AF!9AGGA;:D8?4T!!(?!87!AF?6;!M6>968P6@!:7! 7AG6?=8;<!?=:?!=:7!366;!cDA7?d!F>AG!R=6;96!R6S!?=6>6FA>6S!=:>3A>!:!DA;<8;<!FA>!:;! cA>8<8;:D!9AGGE;8?4Td!,A@6>;!R67?6>;!MAD8?89:D!?=AE<=?!M:>?898M:?67!8;!:!<>:;@! ;:>>:?8P6!?=:?!9=:>?7!?=6!@6P6DAMG6;?!AF!D836>:D!@6GA9>:94S!9:M8?:D87GS!:;@! 8;@8P8@E:D!F>66@AGS!R=8D6!:?!?=6!7:G6!?8G6!M>A@E98;<!?=6!8DDE78A;!AF!:;!8G:<8;:>4! DA7?!E;8?4T!!56:;\%E9!*:;94!36<8;7!=87!?6Q?!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<!:>?89ED:?8;<! ?=87!P6>4!8@6:V!! '=6!<>:P67?!:;@!GA7?!M:8;FED!?67?8GA;4!AF!?=6!GA@6>;!RA>D@S!?=6!A;6!?=:?! MA7783D4!8;PADP67!:DD!A?=6>!?67?8GA;867!?A!R=89=!?=87!6MA9=!GE7?!:;7R6>!f34! P8>?E6!AF!7AG6!E;U;AR;!@69>66!A>!;696778?4S!FA>!R6!36:>!R8?;677!:D7A!?A!?=6! 6Q=:E7?8A;!AF!?=8;U8;<!?=>AE<=!187?A>4hS!87!?=6!?67?8GA;4!AF!?=6!@877ADE?8A;S! ?=6!@87DA9:?8A;S!A>!?=6!9A;FD:<>:?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4T Y !!! ! *:;94!D:?6>!:><E67!?=:?!?=6!DA;<8;<!FA>!:!DA7?!9AGGE;8?4!GE7?!36!G6?!R8?=!9:E?8A;! 369:E76!8?!6QMA767!?=6!@:;<6>!AF!:!3D8;@!E?AM8:;87Gj!?A!M6>968P6!7A986?4!:7!M6>F69?S! R=AD6S!E;8F86@S!9AGMD6?6\E;?A!8?76DFS!:;@!:37ADE?6T Z !!! (;!8?7!GA7?!:33>6P8:?6@!FA>GS!*:;94!AFF6>7!:;!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4! ?=:?!87!;A?!cDA7?d!M6>!76S!3E?!>:?=6>!?=:?!:!DA77!87!9A;7?8?E?8P6!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8?76DFT!! &AGGE;8?4!87S!cR=:?!=:MM6;7!?A!E7jHE67?8A;S!R:8?8;<S!6P6;?S!8GM6>:?8P6j8;!?=6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Y !56:;\%E9!*:;94S!c'=6!(;AM6>:?8P6!&AGGE;8?4Sd!8;!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!6@T! -6?6>!&A;;A>!f,8;;6:MAD87g%A;@A;V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!LT! ! Z !16!E767!?=6!RA>@!7E7M898AE7!?A!@679>836!=AR!A;6!7=AED@!6;9AE;?6>!?=6! 9A;798AE7;677!AF!?=6!DA7?!9AGGE;8?4T!(38@TS!LKT! ! ! Z! R:U6!AF!7A986?4Td ] !(;!?=6!?6Q?!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!*:;94!>6:7767767!R=:?!R6! FE;@:G6;?:DD4!G:4!G6:;!34!?=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4S!GAP8;<!:R:4!F>AG!:;! E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!87!8;P67?6@!8;!:!U8;@!AF!8GG:;6;96!:;@! 6776;?8:D87GT! '=87!9A;96>;!?A!>6:77677!9A;P6;?8A;:D!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!D:><6D4! M>APAU6@!34!?=6!R:47!8;!R=89=!?=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4!87!G8;8G:DD4!:>?89ED:?6@S!:;@! 6P6;!:?!?8G67!7?>:;<6D4!:376;?S!8;!?=6!@879AE>76!AF!ME3D89!:>?T!N=6;!?=6!RA>@!@A67! 6G6><6!:;@!F8;@7!8?7!R:4!8;?A!:!9A;P6>7:?8A;!:3AE?!:>?S!8?!87!:MMD86@!>:?=6>! 8;@879>8G8;:?6D4!?A!:>?!RA>U7S!ME3D89!:>?!M>A_69?7S!GE76EG!6Q=838?8A;7S!7?:?6\FE;@6@! :>?!M>A_69?7S!:;@!M:>?898M:?A>4!RA>U7!?=:?!:>6!>AE?8;6D4!@87G8776@!FA>!:!D:9U!AF! c9>8?89:D8?4Td!(?!87!E;96>?:8;!:7!?A!R=4!?=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4!@A67!;A?!=:P6!:;!:@6HE:?6! AM6>:?8P6!@6F8;8?8A;!R8?=8;!?=6!@879AE>76!AF!:>?S!=AR6P6>S!?=6!6FFA>?!?A!>69A;78@6>!8?! 87!8;7M8>6@!34!:!>69A<;8?8A;!?=:?!8F!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!766G7!;A!DA;<6>!P8:3D6S!8?!87! M:>?D4!@E6!?A!?=6!9A;96M?E:D!D8G8?:?8A;7!AF!6Q87?8;<!M:>:@8<G7!AF!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@! :>?!8?76DFT!!(;!>67MA;76S!?=87!?=6787!R8DD!9>8?89:DD4!6Q:G8;6!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4! ?=>AE<=!:!=87?A>89:D!:;@!?=6A>6?89:D!:;:D4787!AF!8?7!P:>8AE7!9A;F8<E>:?8A;7!8;!A>@6>!?A! FA><6!GA>6!9AGMD6Q!:;@!FDE8@!MA77838D8?867!FA>!:>?!?=:?!6;<:<67!8;!;A?8A;7!AF! 9AGGE;8?4T!!! '=87!?=6787!78?E:?67!HE67?8A;7!9A;96>;8;<!9AGGE;8?4!3:9U!?A!:!FE;@:G6;?:D! M>A3D6G:?89!AF!ME3D89!:>?T!!N=89=!87!?A!7:4S!:>?!78?6@!8;!?=6!ME3D89!7M=6>6!f34!ME3D89! =6>6S!(!:G!E78;<!8?!8;!:!D8?6>:D!76;76!AF!?=6!RA>@!?A!>6F6>!?A!:;!6Q?6>8A>S!AE?78@6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ] !(38@TS!LLT! ! ]! HE:D8?4!AF!ME3D89h!36<:;!:7!:;!6;@6:PA>!R8?=!E?AM89!8;?6;?8A;7\!?A!36:E?8F4!?=6!E>3:;! 6;P8>A;G6;?T!!+8G8D:>D4S!?=6>6!87!:;!8GMD898?!E?AM89!P878A;!AF!8GM>AP8;<!7A98:D!A>@6>! A>!?=6!MA78?8A;:D8?4!AF!96>?:8;!G:><8;:D8a6@!<>AEM7!?=:?!A99EM867!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@! :>?RA>U!:7!R6DDT!!IA?=!:>6!GA?8P:?6@!34!:!;A7?:D<89!F:;?:74!AF!6Q87?6;96!?=:?!=AD@7!?A! >6@E9?8P6!;A?8A;7!AF!7A986?4T!!(;FA>G6@!34!MA7?\GA@6>;87?!9>8?8987G!8;!:>?S!@63:?67! >6<:>@8;<!8@6;?8?4!:;@!?=6!D:><6>!9ADD69?8P6S!:;@!9>8?89:D!?=6A>4!?=87!?=6787!766U7!?A! >6@8>69?!;A>G:?8P6!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!?AR:>@7!:;!:D?A<6?=6>!@8FF6>6;?!GA@6D!AF! 9ADD69?8P8?4!:;@!7E3_69?8P8?4S!A;6!?=:?!@>:R7!EMA;!=6?6>A<6;68?4!>:?=6>!?=:;!A;!:;! E?AM89!8@6:DT!!! .7!:!MA8;?!AF!@6M:>?E>6S!?=6!F8>7?!9=:M?6>!M>AMA767!:!=87?A>89:D!:99AE;?!AF!?=6! ;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;!8?7!P:>8AE7!FA>G7!:;@!9A;F8<E>:?8A;7!:7!8?!87!AE?D8;6@!?=>AE<=! 6:>D4!GA@6>;!M=8DA7AM=4T!!'=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4!=:7!8;@66@!366;!9A;7M89EAE7!8;!:! @8P6>76!>:;<6!AF!M=8DA7AM=89:D!R>8?8;<7S!46?!?=6>6!87!:!766G8;<!D:9U!AF!:!7E37?:;?8P6! :99AE;?!AF!?=6!=87?A>89:D!:;@!?=6A>6?89:D!FAE;@:?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!8?!>6D:?67!?A!:;! :;:D4787!AF!:>?T!'=6!F>:G6RA>U!R8?=8;!R=89=!:!@879E778A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:;@!:>?87?89! M>:9?896!>678@67!>6G:8;7!8;9A;9DE78P6S!:;@!R8DD!GA7?!D8U6D4!9A;?8;E6!?A!D8;<6>!8;!:;! :G38<EAE7!7?:?6!369:E76!AF!?=6!P6>4!:G38<E8?4!?=:?!8;FA>G7!8?T!!! &AGGE;8?4!87!M>8G:>8D4!E;@6>7?AA@!:7!:!9ADD69?8P6!3A@4!AF!7E3_69?7!FA><6@! =:>GA;8AE7D4!EMA;!E;8?4!:;@!9A;76;7E7T!!":96S!<6;@6>S!9ED?E>6S!MAD8?89S!36D86FS! <6A<>:M=89!DA9:?8A;S!M>6F6>6;96S!:;@!7M698F89!;66@!=:P6!:DD!:9?6@!:7!A><:;8a8;<! M>8;98MD67!FA>!P:>8AE7!9AGGE;8?867T!!N=8D6!?=676!9:?6<A>867!:>6!9D6:>D4!@87?8;9?!F>AG! A;6!:;A?=6>S!?=64!:DD!9A;7?8?E?6!9AGGE;8?867!34!:;!8@6:DS!:;@!ED?8G:?6D4!>6@E96! ! ^! 8;@8P8@E:D7!?=:?!9AGM>876!?=676!9AGGE;8?867!?A!6776;?8:D8a6@!P6>78A;7!AF! ?=6G76DP67T! .>?!8;!?=6!ME3D89!7M=6>6!=:7!:D7A!366;!M>6@87MA76@!?A!:;!8@6:DS!F>AG!?=6! 6G6><6;96!AF!-DAM!.>?!8;!?=6!L[^K7!?A!9E>>6;?!6FFA>?7!AF!:>?RA>U!?=:?!7M698F89:DD4! 7AD898?!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!&=:M?6>!L!>6FD69?7!A;!P:>8AE7!M:>:@8<G7!AF!:>?!:;@! 9AGGE;8?4!:;@!=AR!?=64!8;?6>769?!34!R:4!AF!?=68>!E?AM89!AP6>?A;67T!!! &=:M?6>7!J!:;@!Y!78?E:?6!:!@879E778A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!P8:!:>?RA>U7!?=:?!7M6:U! ?A!;A?8A;7!AF!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!?AR:>@7!:;!8;@8P8@E:D8a6@!76;76!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!'=87!U8;@! AF!9ED?E>:D!M>A@E9?8A;!AM6>:?67!A;!:!GA>6!:37?>:9?!D6P6D!:;@!@A67!;A?!;69677:>8D4! 8;PADP6!M:>?898M:;?7T!!+M698F89:DD4S!&=:M?6>!J!6Q:G8;67!?=6!RA>U!AF!0A!1A!+E=!:;@! ?=6!M:>?89ED:>!R:4!8;!R=89=!9AGGE;8?4!87!@6D8;6:?6@!8;!=87!M>:9?896T!!'=87!9=:M?6>! R8DD!G:8;D4!FA9E7!A;!?=6!RA>U!!"##$!fL[[X\JKKLh!R=6>6!+E=!9A;P647!?=6!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!78?6!AF!9A;?67?!:;@!7?>E<<D6T!!'=6!@879E778A;!=6>6!?:U67!:99AE;?!AF! ?=6!@4;:G89!?=:?!6Q87?7!36?R66;!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!D:><6>!9ADD69?8P6!:;@!?=6! 8GMA>?:;96!AF!>69A<;8a8;<!?=6!F>:<8D6!>6D:?8A;7=8M!36?R66;!?=676!?RA!6;?8?867T!!! &=:M?6>!Y!8;?>A@E967!:!F:8>D4!4AE;<!:>?87?S!1:6<E6!/:;<S!:;@!6Q:G8;67!=AR! ?=6!M:>?89ED:>!M8696!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,!fJKK^\JKKWh!8;PAU67!:!;A?8A;! AF!9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!87!9AGMD6?6D4!=6?6>A<6;6AE7!:;@!>:@89:DD4!@879>6?6!F>AG!:;! 6776;?8:D87?!P86R!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!'=6!8;7?:DD:?8A;!@6M89?7!:;!:37?>:9?6@!M:>:DD6D! D:;@79:M6!AF!?=6!GA@6>;!ME3D89!7M=6>6!R=6>6!3A>@6>7S!6@<67S!8;?6>8A>7S!:;@! 6Q?6>8A>7!:>6!:9?8P:?6@!34!8;?6>G8??6;?!3AE?7!AF!P:MA>S!796;?S!:;@!3>66a6T!!/:;<! 6GMDA47!7E9=!6P6>4@:4!A3_69?7!:7!F:;7S!=EG8@8F86>7S!=6:?6>7S!:?AG8a6>7S!:;@!3D8;@7! ! X! ?=:?!=:P6!E;@6><A;6!7D8<=?!7=8F?7!8;!9A;?6Q?!?A!9>6:?6!:!GED?8\76;7A>4!6;P8>A;G6;?! R=6>6!P878?A>7!6QM6>86;96!:;!6;9AE;?6>!?=:?!87!?A?:DD4!E;8HE6!?A!A;6`7!AR;! 7E3_69?8P8?4T!!! "6D48;<!=6:P8D4!A;!?=6!R>8?8;<7!AF!N:D?6>!I6;_:G8;!:;@!56:;\%E9!*:;94S!?=87! 9=:M?6>!@6M:>?7!F>AG!?=6!9AGGA;!;A?8A;!AF!?=6!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!9A=6>6;?!:;@! E;8F86@!7A98:D!FA>G:?8A;T!!(;7?6:@S!?=6!9=:M?6>!FA9E767!A;!8;@8P8@E:D!M6>96M?8A;!:;@! 7E3_69?8P8?4!:7!E;8?7!?=:?!9AGM>876!:;!c8;AM6>:?8P6!9AGGE;8?4Sd!:7!*:;94!ME?7!8?T! '=6!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!:;!8GMA>?:;?!MA8;?!AF!8;P67?8<:?8A;!FA>!9E>>6;?! 9>8?89:D!@63:?67!9A;96>;8;<!96>?:8;!:>?87?89!M>:9?8967!:7!R6DD!:7!D:><6>!MAD8?89:D!877E67T!! '=6!:??6GM?!?A!>6@6F8;6!9AGGE;8?4!87!:!?:7U!AF!_E<<D8;<!36?R66;!8?7!M69ED8:>! 6PA9:?8P6!FA>96!:;@!:;!8@6ADA<89:D!M>67?8<6!R8?=8;!:!9AGMD6Q!G:?>8Q!AF! MAD4GA>M=AE7!9A;@8?8A;7T!!/6?!8?!87!?=87!?:7U!?=:?!9:;!=6DM!?A!9D:>8F4!?=6!3>A:@6>! 8GMD89:?8A;7!AF!GA@6>;87?!:>?S!67M698:DD4!8?7!>6D:?8A;!?A!?=6!ME3D89!7M=6>6T! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! W! &1.-'#"!LV!'=6!&>8?89:D!(;?6>769?8A;!I6?R66;!&AGGE;8?4!:;@!-E3D89!.>?! ! &AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?S!;6R!<6;>6!ME3D89!:>?S!ME3D89!:>?S!>6D:?8A;:D!:67?=6?897T!! '=676!:>6!7AG6!?6>G7!?=:?!:>6!8;9DE@6@!8;!?=6!<DA77:>4!FA>!?=6!9:?:DA<E6! :99AGM:;48;<!+UEDM?E>!->A_6U?6!,E;7?6>!JKKXT!'=6!<DA77:>4!87!:!9AGM6;@8EG!AF! P:>8AE7!?6>G7!@6>8P6@!F>AG!F86D@7!>:;<8;<!F>AG!9ED?E>:D!?=6A>4S!M=8DA7AM=4S!E>3:;! ?=6A>4S!:>9=8?69?E>:D!=87?A>4!:;@!=EG:;8?867!?A!M>AP8@6!:@6HE:?6!PA9:3ED:>4!FA>!?=6! 6P6>!FDE9?E:?8;<!>=6?A>89!AF!:>?!:7!8?!>6D:?67!?A!?=6!9A;@8?8A;7!AF!ME3D89!7M:96T!(?! :9U;ARD6@<67!?=6!8;:38D8?4!AF!9A;P6;?8A;:D!D:;<E:<6!?A!<>:7M!?=6!8;F8;8?6!9AGMD6Q8?4! AF!;6R!M=6;AG6;:S!M:>?89ED:>D4!;6R!E>3:;!M=6;AG6;:!:7!8?!87!6P8@6;?!8;!?=6!U64! ?6>G7!D87?6@!6:>D86>T!!(;!?=6!FA>6RA>@S!9E>:?A>!I>8<8??6!$>:;a6;!;A?67!?=:?!?=6! <DA77:>4!87S!c:!9ADD69?8A;!R=89=!8;!;A!R:4!9D:8G7!?A!36!9AGMD6?6S!3E?!8;7?6:@!87!AM6;! ?A!FE>?=6>!@6P6DAMG6;?Td ^ !(;!?=6!7:G6!R:4S!?=6!?:7U!?A!@6F8;6!?=6!?6>G!9AGGE;8?4!87! :;!E;@6>?:U8;<!?=:?!G:4!;6P6>!F8;:D8a6!:;@!R8DD!A;D4!9A;?8;E6!?A!6QM:;@T!!! 'A!?=87!6;@S!8?!G:4!36!<6;6>:?8P6!?A!DAAU!8;?A!?=6!69EG6;89:D!@87?8;9?8A;7!AF! ?=6!?6>GS!9AGGE;8?4T!(;?6>67?8;<D4S!?=6>6!:>6!?RA!@8FF6>6;?!6?4GADA<867!?=:?!:>6! M>AP8@6@!34!?=6!)QFA>@!#;<D87=!089?8A;:>4T!$8>7?S!?=6!GA>6!M=8DADA<89:DD4!P:D8@! FA>G:?8A;!AF!?=6!RA>@!9AG67!F>AG!c9AG!k!GE;87d!R=89=!8;@89:?67!:!76;76!AF!368;<! 3AE;@S!A3D8<:?6@S!A>!8;@63?6@!?A<6?=6>T!!'=6!GA>6!FADU\6?4GADA<89:D!FA>G:?8A;!AF! c9AG!k!E;E7d!7M698F867!:;!:37A>M?8A;!8;?A!A;6;677T!!'=6!M=8DADA<89:D!FA>G6>S!R=89=! @679>8367!:!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!3AE;@!34!:!76;76!AF!GE?E:D!8;@63?6@;677S! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ^ !I>8<8??6!$>:;a6;S!c+UEDM?E>!->A_6U?6!,E;7?6>Td!%80"C50$'-H$#I'85,-;0'*,5'$-JK! fBAD;V!N67?F:D879=67!%:;@67GE76EGS!JKKXhS!YJYT! ! [! >67A;:?67!R8?=!?=6!8@6:!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!?4M6!AF!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?T!'=6!D:??6>! 8DDE7?>:?67!:!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:;!A><:;89:DD4!FA>G6@!E;8A;T!1AR6P6>S!3A?=!AF! ?=676!6?4GADA<867!:>6!@66MD4!8;FA>G6@!34!?=6!8;:38D8?4!AF!GA@6>;!R67?6>;!MAD8?89:D! ?=AE<=?!?A!9AGM>6=6;@!:!7E3_69?!364A;@!:;!6776;?8:D87?!GA@6DT!!(;!?=6!3AAUS! @#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,S!R>8?6>!O6A><67!C:;!06;!.3366D6!6QMD:8;7!?=:?!8;!3A?=! 9:767S!c7A98:D!6776;?8:D87G!P8?8:?6l7m!?=6!P6>4!9A;@8?8A;!AF!?=6!9AGGE;:D!>6D:?8A;S! ;:G6D4!?=6!@8FF6>6;96!36?R66;!78;<ED:>!7E3_69?8P8?867!R=89=!87!M:>?!AF!R=:?!?=64! 7=:>6!34!368;<!8;!9AGGA;Td X ! ':U8;<!8;?A!9A;78@6>:?8A;!?=6!8@6:7!M>AMA76@!34!'=AG:7!1A3367!8;! A'G+1591*!fL^]LhS!8;@8P8@E:D7!:>6!?A!36!:3D6!?A!c>6:@!:;@!U;AR!R=:?!:>6!?=6! ?=AE<=?7S!:;@!M:778A;7!AF!A?=6>!G6;d!369:E76!M6AMD6!:>6!A7?6;783D4!?>:;7M:>6;?! 7E3_69?7!?=:?!7=:>6!9AGGA;:D8?867!R8?=!A;6!:;A?=6>T W !!!'=676!8;@8P8@E:D7!7E>>6;@6>! ?=68>!F>66@AG!?A!:!7AP6>68<;!R=A!87!?A!M>AP8@6!769E>8?4!F>AG!?=6!@:;<6>7!AF!?=6!7?:?6! AF!;:?E>6T!'=6!7A98:D!3A@4!87!>ED6@!34!:!=6:@!E;@6>!R=A76!D6:@6>7=8M!?=6!G6G36>7! A>!G6G36>7=8M!:>6!7E37EG6@T!'=87!7AP6>68<;!>6M>676;?7!?=6!?=AE<=?7!:;@!9A;96>;7! AF!?=6!M6AMD6S!:;@!6G3A@867!?=6!7AED!AF!?=6!ME3D89T!! &A;?>:7?8;<D4S!?=6!#;D8<=?6;G6;?!P878A;!AF!:!9ADD69?8P6!@6M89?7!:!76DF\ <AP6>;8;<!7A986?4!?=:?!87!FA>G6@!?=>AE<=!:!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?T!!'=87!9A;?>:9?!>6FD69?7!:! GE?E:D!:<>66G6;?!36?R66;!6HE:D!7E3_69?7!R=A!E;8?6!EMA;!?=68>!AR;!:99A>@!?A!FA>G! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! X !O6A><6!C:;!06;!.3366D6S!c(;?>A@E9?8A;Sd!8;!@#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,S!6@T!'=6! ,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S! L[[LhS!Q88T! ! W !'=AG:7!1A3367S!A'G+1591*!f&:G3>8@<6V!&:G3>8@<6!2;8P6>78?4!->677S!L[[XhS!LKT! ! LK! :!9AGGE;8?4T!!16>6S!:!M>6@6?6>G8;6@!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!6HE:D8?4!87!?=6!3:787!AF!:! 9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!87!67?:3D87=6@!A;!7=:>6@!8;?6>67?7!:;@!9AGGA;:D8?867T!!! .99A>@8;<!?A!56:;!5:9HE67!"AE776:ES!9AGGE;8?4!:9=86P67!:;!6<:D8?:>8:;! D836>:D87G!369:E76!8?!87!FA>G6@!>6<:>@D677!AF!38:767!FAE;@6@!A;!>:96S!76QS!A>! >6D8<8A;T [ !!'=87!GA@6DS!=AR6P6>S!F:8D7!?A!<>:7M!?=6!8GMA>?:;96!AF!>69A<;8a8;<!?=6! 6FF69?7!:;@!@8FF6>6;967!?=:?!:>6!<6;6>:?6@!34!:!@8P6>76!3A@4!MAD8?89T! '=6!O6>G:;!M=8DA7AM=6>S!O6A><!16<6DS!AFF6>7!:;A?=6>!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4! R=6>6!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!@A67!;A?!6Q87?!36FA>6!7A986?4S!3E?!?=>AE<=!8;?6>\>6D:?8A;!R8?=! A?=6>7T!!$A>!16<6DS!9AGGE;8?4!87!;A?!:;!6Q?6>;:D!FA>96!?=:?!9:?6<A>8a67!7E3_69?7!8;?A! <>AEM7i!>:?=6>!?=6!9AGGE;8?4!87!8;?6>;:DS!R8?=8;!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D7!?=6G76DP67T! &AGGE;8?4!6;:3D67!?=68>!368;<T LK ! N=8D6!?=676!@8P6>76!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>6!9D6:>D4!@87?8;9?!F>AG!A;6! :;A?=6>S!?=64!:>6!:DD!@6?6>G8;6@!34!:;!8@6:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4!67?:3D87=6@!EMA;!;A?8A;7! AF!E;8?4!:;@!9A;76;7E7T!!(;!8?7!GA7?!@87?E>38;<!FA>GS!?=676!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!9:;! 369AG6!:!FA>GED:!FA>!:E?=A>8?:>8:;!F:7987G!R=6>6!7A98:D!@8FF6>6;967!:>6!>6@E96@!?A! ?=6!MA8;?!R=6>6!?=64!369AG6!8;@87?8;<E87=:3D6T! (;!9A;?>:7?!?A!?=87!6776;?8:D87G!?=:?!DAAU7!:?!?=6!9AGGE;:D!7AD6D4!FA>!?=6!>87U! AF!MA78?8;<!?=6!7?:?6!:7!7E3_69?S!R6!GE7?!9A;78@6>!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!:!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?T!!I4! ?=6!@8FF6>6;?!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>?89ED:?6@!:3AP6S!:!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?!:77EG67!?=6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [ !56:;\5:9HE67!"AE776:ES!E9'-%#8+1"-@#*5$185!f1:>GA;@7RA>?=V!'=6!-6;<E8;!->677S! L[^WhT! ! LK !OTNT$T!16<6DS!H9+"#,#C9<-#.-=+495S!6@T!'T,T!B;AQ!f%A;@A;V!)QFA>@!2;8P6>78?4!->677S! L[^XhS!+LWYT! ! LL! FA>G:?8A;!AF!76DF\@6?6>G8;8;<!7E3_69?7!R=A!F>66D4!:776G3D6!?A!FA>G!:!9AGGE;8?4T!! '=6!;A?8A;!AF!:!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?!;6<D69?7!?=6!@8FF6>6;967!36?R66;!8;@8P8@E:D7!AF!:! 9AGGE;8?4!8;!A>@6>!?A!A3D8?6>:?6S!A>!M6>=:M7!9AGMD89:?6S!?=6!MA7783D6!=4MA?=6767!AF! ?=68>!:37ADE?6!6HE:D8?4S!G6:;8;<!?=:?!7AG6!G:4!6;?6>!8;?A!?=6!9A;?>:9?!&#$'!6HE:D! ?=:;!A?=6>7T!.D7AS!?=6!9A;96M?!AF!:!7A98:D!9A;?>:9?!F:8D7!?A!:@@>677!P6>4!8GMA>?:;?! 6D6G6;?7!?=:?!<8P6!D6<8?8G:94!?A!8?7!:E?=A>8?4!:7!:!?=6A>4T!N=6>6!@A!?=676!76DF\ @6?6>G8;6@!8;@8P8@E:D7!F>66D4!6;<:<6!R8?=!6:9=!A?=6>b!1AR!:>6!?=64!9A;7?8?E?6@b! 1AR!@A!?=64!F>66D4!:776G3D6!R8?=!A;6!:;A?=6>b!! "6F6>>8;<!3:9U!?A!?=6!?RA!6?4GADA<867!M>6P8AE7D4!7?:?6@S!3A?=!A><:;8987?!:;@! 9A;?>:9?E:D!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!A379E>6!?=6!6776;?8:D87G!AF!:!7E3_69?!8GG:;6;?!?A! 8?76DFT!!!IA?=!?=6!6;?8?4!?=:?!M>696@67!8?7!9A;7?8?E6;?7!f9AG\E;E7h!A>!?=6!9A;7?8?E6;?! ?=:?!87!:D>6:@4!:!M:>?!AF!?=6!R=AD6!f9AG\GE;87h!F:8D!?A!G:U6!9D6:>!?=68>!8;:E<E>:D! 9A;@8?8A;7T!!.7!:!>67ED?S!?=64!M>A966@!?A!M6>M6?E:?6!:!>6@E9?8P6!76;?8G6;?!?AR:>@7! 9AGGE;8?4S!FD:??6;8;<!?=6!MA?6;?8:D!AF!7A98:D!@8FF6>6;96T!'=676!FA>G7!AF!7A98:D! 6776;?8:D87G!@67?>A4!?=6!P6>4!9A;@8?8A;!AF!?=6!9AGGE;:D!>6D:?8A;S!;:G6D4!?=6! @8P6>78?4!36?R66;!8;@8P8@E:D7!R8?=8;!:!9ADD69?8P6T!! &A;?6GMA>:>4!:>?!:D7A!M:>?898M:?67!8;!?=6!>=6?A>89!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!8?!9D6:>D4! 9AG67!8;?A!MD:4!8;!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?S!;6R!<6;>6!ME3D89!:>?S!:;@!>6D:?8A;:D! :67?=6?897S!:7!8?!=:7!366;!@6D8;6:?6@!8;!?=6!+UEDM?E>!->A_6U?6!,E;7?6>!JKKX! 9:?:DA<E6!<DA77:>4T!!'=6>6!:>6!?RA!U64!?6>G7S!@8:DA<89:D!:67?=6?897!:;@!7A98:D! M>:9?896S!R=89=!=:P6!6G6><6@!8;!>696;?!46:>7!3E?!:>6!;A?!8;9DE@6@!8;!?=6!<DA77:>4T!! I6!?=:?!:7!8?!G:4S!?=676!@6P6DAMG6;?7!9:;;A?!36!6QMD:8;6@!R8?=AE?!:;! ! LJ! E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!+M:;;8;<!F>AG!M>A_69?7!?=:?!:@@>677! P:>8AE7!G8;A>8?4!<>AEM7!?A!6P6;!?=6!:>?!RA>D@!8?76DFS!7E9=!M>:9?8967!9A;?8;EAE7D4! 6;9AGM:77!7M698F89!9AGGE;8?867S!:;@!8;!@A8;<!7AS!9A;76HE6;?D4!8;PAU6!?=6!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!:7!R6DDT!!! 1AR6P6>S!9ED?E>:D!M>A@E9?8A;!AF!?=87!U8;@!=:7!366;!FAE;@!?A!<6;6>:?6!:! 9A;96>;!?=:?!P:>867!F>AG!@AE3?!?A!@66M!7U6M?8987GT!!'=676!F66D8;<7!7?6G!F>AG!:! 76;?8G6;?!M>67EG8;<!?=:?!R=8D6!M:>?898M:?A>4!RA>U!:;@!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!@A! 7=6@!D8<=?!A;!877E67!?=:?!6;9AGM:77!:!R8@6!>:;<6!AF!M6>?8;6;?!M>A3D6G7!8;!7A986?4S! ?=64!M6>=:M7!M6>M6?E:?6!FA>G7!AF!;6<:?8A;!:7!R6DDT!! '=6!6:>D4!L[[K7!7:R!:!<>AR8;<!8;?6>67?!8;!?=6!MAD8?89:D!E767!AF!:>?S!R=89=!8;! ?E>;!D6@!?A!?=6!>876!:;@!>69A<;8?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!M>A@E9?8A;T!NA>U7! E;@6>!?=87!9:?6<A>4!R6>6!AF?6;!?8G67!M:>?898M:?A>4S!:;@!M>8G:>8D4!FA9E76@!A;!877E67! ?=:?!@6:D?!R8?=!7A98:DS!69A;AG89S!9ED?E>:DS!:;@!MAD8?89:D!9A;96>;7T!!&AGGE;8?4\3:76@! :>?!M>A_69?7!<6;6>:DD4!6;9AE>:<6@!:9?8P6!M:>?898M:?8A;!AF!?=6!ME3D89!34!M>AP8@8;<!:! MD:?FA>G!FA>!7A98:D!<>AEM7!?A!9A;F>A;?S!9=:DD6;<6S!:;@!9AGGE;89:?6!7A986?:D!G:??6>7! 8;!:!9AAM6>:?8P6!M>A9677!R8?=!:;!:>?87?T!!067M8?6!?=6!9A;96>?6@!6FFA>?!?A!>6@6F8;6! :>?87?89!M>:9?896!8;!?=6!ME3D89!>6:DGS!G:;4!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!M>A_69?7!AF!?=6! L[[K7!R6>6!FAE;@6@!A;!:!M>A3D6G:?89!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!E;8F86@! 7A98:D!FA>G:?8A;T!!! ! LY! '=6!MAD8?89:D!9D8G:?6!@E>8;<!?=87!?8G6!R:7!9=:>:9?6>8a6@!34!9A;76>P:?8P6! 38:767!7EMMA>?6@!34!?=6!"6:<:;gIE7=!:@G8;87?>:?8A;T LL !!.>?87?7!R6>6!AF?6;!9>8?898a6@! FA>!9>6:?8;<!8;@696;?!:;@!7E3P6>78P6!RA>U!?=:?!7EMMA76@D4!?=>6:?6;6@!?>:@8?8A;!:;@! F:G8D4!P:DE67T!!'=87!M6>8A@S!U;AR;!:7!?=6!&ED?E>6!N:>7S!369:G6!?=6!3:9U@>AM!FA>!?=6! 6Q=838?8A;!@0"50$'-+*-385+#*T!&E>:?6@!34!,:>4!5:;6!5:9A3!8;!L[[J\L[[YS!@0"50$'-+*- 385+#*!R:7!:!R:?6>7=6@!GAG6;?!8;!?=6!@6P6DAMG6;?!AF!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!:;@! 9ADD:3A>:?8P6!ME3D89!:>?!M>:9?8967T!!.99A>@8;<!?A!8?7!M>677!>6D6:76S!! &ED?E>6!8;!.9?8A;!67?:3D87=6@!:!;6R!PA9:3ED:>4!R8?=8;!?=6!<6;>6!AF!E>3:;! A>86;?6@!79EDM?E>6!6Q=838?8A;7T!!&ED?E>6!8;!.9?8A;!?67?6@!?=6!?6>>8?A>4!AF! ME3D89!8;?6>:9?8A;!:;@!M:>?898M:?8A;S!?=6!>AD6!AF!?=6!:>?87?!:7!:;!:9?8P6!7A98:D! FA>96S!:>?87?\@>8P6;!6@E9:?8A;:D!M>A<>:GG8;<!:7!:;!6776;?8:D!M:>?!AF!?=6! :>?RA>US!:;@!M>A_69?7!?=:?!6Q87?6@!AP6>!:;!6Q?6;@6@!M6>8A@!AF!?8G6S!;A?!_E7?! :7!7M69?:?A>!A>86;?6@!M>A_69?7!FA>!3>86F!P86R8;<T LJ !!! ! (;?6;@6@!?A!9=:DD6;<6!?=6!A>?=A@AQ867!AF!ME3D89!:>?S!@0"50$'-+*-385+#*!R:7!:! 9A;96>?6@!6FFA>?!?A!>6@6F8;6!:>?87?89!M>:9?896!?=>AE<=!ME3D89!M:>?898M:?8A;S!;A;\A3_69?! A>86;?6@!:>?87?89!M>A@E9?8A;S!:;@!?6GMA>:>4!@879E>78P6!:>?!FA>G7T!!'=6!6Q=838?8A;! 8;9DE@6@!68<=?!M>A_69?7!7?>E9?E>6@!:7!9AGGE;8?4!9ADD:3A>:?8A;7!R=6>6!P86R6>7!R6>6! ;A!DA;<6>!M:778P6!7M69?:?A>7!3E?!:77EG6@!?=6!>AD6!AF!:9?8P6!:>?\G:U6>7T! @0"50$'-+*-385+#*!R:7!8;!M:>?!:!9>8?8HE6!AF!6Q87?8;<!FA>G7!AF!ME3D89!:>?S!D8U6! D:><6\79:D6!:37?>:9?!79EDM?E>6T!'=6>6!R:7!:!@678>6!?A!3>A:@6;!9A;P6;?8A;7!AF!:>?87?89! M>A@E9?8A;!8;!?=6!ME3D89!7M=6>6!34!8;?6>769?8;<!:>?!R8?=!7A98:D!877E67T!!'=87! >6?=8;U8;<!F>6HE6;?D4!6;<:<6@!M6AMD6!:FF69?6@!34!MAP6>?4S!1(C!8;F69?8A;S!@>E<!E76S! :;@!7A986?:D!G:><8;:D8a:?8A;T!!(;!?=676!9:767S!8?!9:;!36!7:8@!?=:?!6776;?8:D87?!7?>:?6<867! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LL !5ED86!.ED?!:;@!A?=6>7S!6@7T!3$5-;155'$,L-M#N-59'-@0"50$'-?1$,-@91*4'>-3&'$+81O- f*6R!/A>UV!*6R!/A>U!2;8P6>78?4!->677S!L[[[hS!ZKT! LJ !c+9EDM?E>6!&=89:<A!187?A>4!:;@!->676;?!->A<>:GSd!E;@:?6@!M>677!>6D6:76S!;TMT! ! LZ! R6>6!E?8D8a6@!R8?=!>6<:>@7!?A!G8;A>8?4!<>AEM7!8;!A>@6>!?A!F:98D8?:?6!:!9AGGA;!<A:D!AF! 7AG6!7A>?S!R=6?=6>!8?!36!6QM>6776@!:7!:!FA>G!AF!MAD8?89:D!:9?8P87G!A>!:!78GMD6!76>P896! :9?T!!'=87!369AG67!M>A3D6G:?89!369:E76!8;!GA7?!AF!?=676!M>A_69?7S!?=6!8@6;?8?867!AF! ?=6!M:>?898M:;?7!:>6!7EMM>6776@!34!?=6!M>676;?:?8A;!AF!:;!:>?8F898:D!9A=6>6;96!AF!:! 9ADD69?8P6!8@6;?8?4T!!$A>!6Q:GMD6S!0:;86D!5A76M=!,:>?8;6a`!M>A_69?!@#*,'P0'*8',-#.-1- Q',50$'!fL[[Yh!8;PADP6@!=E;@>6@7!AF!G:>9=6>7!F>AG!,6Q89:;\.G6>89:;!:;@!.F>89:;\ .G6>89:;!@6796;?!?A!FA>G!:!9AGGE;:D!M>AG6;:@6!?=>AE<=!6?=;89:DD4!@8P6>76! ;68<=3A>=AA@7!8;!&=89:<A!EMA;!?=6G67!>6<:>@8;<!8GG8<>:;?!D:3A>!:;@!8@6;?8?4! MAD8?897T LY !!'=6!=8<=D8<=?8;<!AF!G:><8;:D8a6@!:;@!@876;F>:;9=876@!7A98:D!<>AEM7!8;! ,:>?8;6a`7!M>A_69?!?A!9AE;?6>!?=68>!D:9U!AF!:<6;94!:;@!PA896!8;@89:?67!:;!AP6>\ @6?6>G8;:?8A;!AF!8@6;?8?4!:;@!:!>68;FA>96G6;?!AF!:;!:MM:>:?E7!AF!MAR6>!8;8?8:?6@!34! ?=6!:>?87?T!!067M8?6!?=6!<AA@!8;?6;?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!RA>US!?=6!8GMD898?!E?AM89! P878A;!AF!8GM>AP8;<!7A98:D!A>@6>!>69:DD7!:!;A7?:D<89!F:;?:74!AF!6Q87?6;96!?=:?!>6D867!A;! <6;6>:D8a:?8A;7!:;@!7?6>6A?4M67T!!! (;!?=6!7:G6!R:4S!?=6!FA>G7!AF!9ED?E>:D!M>A@E9?8A;!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!?>86@! ?A!9>8?8HE6!:D7A!9:>>86@!E?AM89!8GMD89:?8A;7!:7!R6DDT!!'=6!ME3D89!:>?!GAP6G6;?!AF!?=6! L[^K7!:;@!L[XK7S!:D7A!U;AR;!:7!-DAM!.>?S!R:7!@AG8;:?6@!34!D:><6\79:D6!GA@6>;87?! 79EDM?E>6!78?6@!8;!ME3D89!7M:967!?A!:67?=6?89:DD4!6@8F4!ME3D89!@AG:8;T!!'=676!RA>U7S! D8U6!.D6Q:;@6>!&:D@6>`7!A1-Q$1*>'-/+5',,'!fL[^Xh!8;!O>:;@!":M8@7S!,89=8<:;S! 6QMD898?D4!7AE<=?!?A!:??>:9?!;6R!3E78;677S!9:M8?:D8a6!A;!?AE>87GS!:;@!M>AGA?6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LY !,8RA;!BRA;S!)*'-H"18'-3.5'$-3*#59'$L-%+5'R%C'8+.+8-3$5-1*>-A#815+#*1"-F>'*5+5<! f&:G3>8@<6g%A;@A;V!'=6!,('!->677S!JKKJhS!LJWT! ! ! L]! >678@6;?8:D!@6P6DAMG6;?T LZ !!0E>8;<!?=87!?8G6S!-DAM!.>?!FE;9?8A;6@!?A!8GM>AP6!?=6! 69A;AG89!:;@!7A98:D!9A;@8?8A;7!AF!:!ME3D89!7M:96S!D8U6!98P89!96;?6>7S!E;8P6>78?4! 9:GME767S!:;@!MD:a:7!AF!F6@6>:D!3E8D@8;<7S!GE9=!D8U6!?=6!8GMED767!?=:?!@>AP6!?=6! M>A@E9?8A;!AF!:!<>6:?!@6:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?RA>UT!!! '=6!FE;@:G6;?:D!M:>:DD6D7!36?R66;!-DAM!.>?!:;@!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!RA>U! 3A?=!7M>8;<!F>AG!E?AM89!8;;E6;@AT!!);!A;6!=:;@S!69A;AG89!:;@!MAD8?89:D!FA>967! 6;@A>76@!?=6!8;?6<>:?8A;!AF!GA;EG6;?:D!79EDM?E>67!R8?=8;!ME3D89!7M:967!?A!:9=86P6! 7AG6!7A>?!AF!9A=6>6;?S!=:>GA;8AE7!7M:96T!!);!?=6!A?=6>!=:;@S!:>?87?7!M>A@E98;<! 9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?RA>U!8@6;?8F4!:!M:>?89ED:>!<>AEM!AF!M6AMD6!R=A!7=:>6!96>?:8;! 98>9EG7?:;967!:;@!9D:778F4!?=6G!:7!:!E;8F86@S!9A=6>6;?!9AGGE;8?4T!!'=6!F:;?:74!AF!:! =:>GA;8AE7!7M:96!G8>>A>7!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!:!=:>GA;8AE7!9AGGE;8?4!369:E76!3A?=! 76>P6!E?AM89!AP6>?A;67!?=:?!:@G8;87?6>!?A!7A98:D!>67MA;7838D8?4!:;@!3E>@6;T!!! 1AR6P6>S!8?!87!;A?!?A!7:4!?=:?!9ED?E>:D!M>A@E9?8A;!7=AED@!P66>!:R:4!F>AG! :>?RA>U!?=:?!@6:D7!R8?=!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!(?!87!8GMA>?:;?!?A!8@6;?8F4!?=6!;:?E>6! AF!:!E?AM8:;!P878A;!AF!7M:96!:;@!7A986?4!:;@!>6@8>69?!AE>76DP67!?A!:!GA>6!FDE8@! E;@6>7?:;@8;<T!!'A!36<8;!AE>!>6?=8;U8;<S!R6!GE7?!F8>7?!:9U;ARD6@<6!?=6! E;8P6>7:D8a8;<!?6;@6;9867!?=676!FA>G7!AF!:>?!:>6!8;9D8;6@!?A!?:U6T!!'=6;S!:!G:_A>! >6:77677G6;?!AF!?=6!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4!GE7?!?:U6!MD:96T!!$>6;9=!R>8?6>!56:;\%E9! *:;94!M>AP8@67!P:DE:3D6!?=6A>6?89:D!8;78<=?!8;?A!?=6!HE67?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;!?6>G7! AF!:!c368;<\8;\9AGGA;Td L] !!*:;94S!8;!=87!6;E;98:?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!MA8;?7!?AR:>@7! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LZ !(38@TS!^KT! L] !56:;\%E9!*:;94S!c'=6!(;AM6>:?8P6!&AGGE;8?4Sd!8;!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!6@T! -6?6>!&A;;A>!f,8;;6:MAD87g%A;@A;V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!JKT! ! L^! ?=6!+*!AF!368;<\8;\9AGGA;!:7!?=6!9=:DD6;<6!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!16!9A;?8;E67S!c?=6! HE67?8A;!7=AED@!36!?=6!9AGGE;8?4!AF!368;<S!:;@!;A?!?=6!368;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!)>!8F! 4AE!M>6F6>S!?=6!9AGGE;8?4!AF!6Q87?6;96S!:;@!;A?!?=6!6776;96!AF!9AGGE;8?4Td L^ !! &AGGE;8?4!@6?6>G8;6@!34!:;!6776;96!A>!9AGGA;!368;<!DA767!?=6!+*!AF!368;<\8;\ 9AGGA;T!!":?=6>S!9AGGE;8?4!87!:!G:??6>!AF!6Q87?6;96!8;7AF:>!:7!8?!87!+*!9AGGA;T! '=6!?RA!:>?RA>U7!AE?D8;6@!8;!9=:M?6>7!J!:;@!Y!3A?=!8;?6>>A<:?6!?=6! 9AGGE;8?4!AF!368;<S!;A?!?=6!368;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!0A!1A!+E=`7!!"##$!fL[[X\JKKLh! :;@!1:6<E6!/:;<`7!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,-fJKK^\JKKWh!36<8;!R8?=!:! HE67?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;7?6:@!AF!:;!8@6;?8F89:?8A;!AF!:!7M698F89!9AGGE;8?4T!!(;!?=87! R:4S!?=676!RA>U7!:>6!:3D6!?A!M>AGM?!:!<6;6>:?8P6!@879E778A;!:3AE?!?=6!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!R=6>6!?=6!A3_69?8P6!87!?A!G:8;?:8;!:!76DF\>6FD6Q8P6!9>8?8HE6!:3AE?! 9ADD69?8P6!FA>G:?8A;!:;@!8@6;?8?4T!!!! .D?=AE<=!?=676!RA>U7!:>6!78?6@!R8?=8;!:!<:DD6>4!9A;?6Q?S!?=64!:>6!P6>4!GE9=! c9AGGE;8?4\3:76@d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c)F!I68;<\8;\&AGGA;Sd!8;!&AGGE;8?4!:?!%AA76!#;@7S!6@T!'=6! ,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S! L[[LhS!LT! ! LX! &1.-'#"!JV!'=6!"6D:?8A;7=8M!I6?R66;!?=6!(;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!&ADD69?8P6! ! ! '=6>6!87!:!7?>A;<!?6;@6;94!?A!P86R!9AGGE;8?4!?=>AE<=!:!@E:D!D6;7S!68?=6>! 6;?8>6D4!MA78?8P6!A>!R=ADD4!;6<:?8P6T!!);!A;6!=:;@S!?=6!>6@6GM?8P6!:7M69?!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!P6=89D6!?A!GA38D8a6!?=6!6;6><867!AF!?=6!GA7?!@8P6>76!<>AEM7!87! F>6HE6;?D4!6QMDA8?6@!?A!FE>?=6>!:!MA78?8P87?!8@6:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!);!?=6!A?=6>!=:;@S! ?=87!MA78?8P87?!8@6:D!6:78D4!369AG67!:!?=>6:?!?A!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!=6?6>A<6;68?4!34!?=6! P6>4!:9?!AF!FA>G8;<!:!E;8F86@!9ADD69?8P6T!!! ! '=6!?6;78A;!36?R66;!?=676!?RA!9A;96M?7!87!:!>69E>>6;?!?=6G:?89!8;!?=6!RA>U! AF!:>?87?!0A!1A!+E=T!!(;!?9#-3&-?'S!fJKKKh!?=AE7:;@7!AF!8;@8796>;83D6!F:967!AF! FA>G6>!=8<=!79=AAD!9D:77G:?67!:>6!?:U6;!F>AG!?=6!:>?87?`7!AD@!46:>3AAU7!:;@!M>8;?6@! A;?A!7=66?7!AF!R:DDM:M6>T!!$>AG!:!@87?:;96S!?=6!8@6;?8?867!AF!?=6!?8;4!AP:D!MA>?>:8?7! 3DE>!:;@!G6><6!8;?A!:!76:!AF!76M8:!?A;67T!!(;!M+49-%89##"-7*+R!#$&!fL[[Xh!YKK! 79=AAD3A4!_:9U6?7!:>6!76R;!?A<6?=6>!?A!FA>G!A;6!G:778P6!E;8?T!'=6!=ADDAR!3A@867! ?=:?!9A;7?8?E?6!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!E;8?4!9A;_E>6!:;!66>86!6GM?8;677!8;!?=6!:9?!AF! 9A;FA>G8?4T!'=AE7:;@7!AF!7?:8;D677!7?66D!:>G4\7?4D6!@A<!?:<7!:>6!:776G3D6@!?A!?:U6! ?=6!7=:M6!AF!:!G:_67?89!G6?:D!>A36!>676G3D8;<!R:>D8U6!:>GA>!8;!?=6!8;7?:DD:?8A;! %#&'()*'!fJKKL\JKKYhT!!'=6!>6M6?8?8A;!AF!9A;<>E6;?!E;8?7!?A!6G3A@4!:!D:><6>!R=AD6! =:7!@6F8;6@!+E=`7!M>:9?896!:;@!=87!ME>7E6@!8;?6>67?!8;!?=6!>6D:?8A;7=8M!36?R66;!?=6! 8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6T LX !! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LX !)?=6>!RA>U7!34!0A!1A!+E=!?=:?!R>67?D6!R8?=!?=6!>6D:?8A;7=8M!36?R66;!?=6! 8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!8;9DE@6!H02"+8-!+40$',!fL[[WhS!T##$&15L-?'"8#&'- ! LW! ! .!RA>U!?=:?!M:>?89ED:>D4!6QM>67767!?=87!9AGM6DD8;<!@4;:G89!87!!"##$!fL[[X\ JKKLhT!!(;!?=87!M8696!P878?A>7!:>6!8;P8?6@!?A!7?6M!EM!A;?A!:!<>8@@6@!<D:77!FDAA>T!! I6;6:?=!?=6!<D:77!7E>F:96S!7G:DD!7M69U7!AF!9ADA>!:>6!P8783D6!R=89=S!EMA;!9DA76>! 6Q:G8;:?8A;S!:>6!>6P6:D6@!?A!36!?=6!?8;4!M:DG7!AF!GA>6!?=:;!LWKSKKK!F8<E>8;67T!! '=676!F8<E>8;67!:>6!:776G3D6@!?A!3E??>677!?=6!R68<=?!AF!?=6!<D:77!FDAA>S!:7!R6DD!:7!?=6! M6AMD6!7?:;@8;<!A;!8?T!!'=68>!9ADD69?8P6!7?>6;<?=!9:;!68?=6>!36!M6>968P6@!:7! 9ADD:3A>:?8P6!:9?8A;!A>!?=6!6FF8986;94!AF!?4>:;;4T!$>:<8D6!A;!?=68>!AR;S!3E?!_A8;?D4! 9:M:3D6!AF!@6GA;7?>:?8;<!MAR6>FED!7?>6;<?=S!?=6!EM?E>;6@!:>G7!AF!?=6!F8<E>8;67!:>6! :3D6!?A!3>:96!?=6!FAA?G:>U7!AF!?=A76!R=A!R:DU!:3AP6!?=6GT!!'=6!FA>G:D!E;8?4!AF!?=6! R=AD6!87!@6M6;@6;?!EMA;!3A?=!?=6!E;8FA>G8?4!:;@!9A;FA>G8?4!AF!8?7!M:>?7T!!(F!A;6! F8<E>6!87!AE?!AF!MD:96!A>!8;@89:?67!@8FF6>6;96S!?=6!8;?6<>8?4!AF!?=6!RA>U!:7!:!R=AD6!87! 9AGM>AG876@T!!'=87!F>:<8D8?4!36?R66;!?=6!6FFA>?7!AF!:!F6R!:;@!?=6!MAR6>!AF!?=6! G:7767S!36?R66;!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!7?>6;<?=!AF!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!87!9D6:>D4!@6M89?6@! 8;!!"##$T!! ! '=6!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4!>6PADP67!:>AE;@!?=6!9AGMD6Q!FA>G7!AF! 8@6;?8F89:?8A;!?=:?!6Q87?!36?R66;!8;@8P8@E:D7!:;@!?=6!D:><6>!9ADD69?8P6!6;?8?4T!!'=6! @6D89:?6!>6D:?8A;7=8M!36?R66;!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!:>6!U64!9A;96M?7!8;! ?=6!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!(;!+E=`7!?9#-3&-?'S!?=6>6!87!:!D:9U!AF!@87?8;9?8A;! 36?R66;!?=6!78;<ED:>!:;@!MDE>:DS!R=8D6!?=6!78;<ED:>!87!9AGMD6?6D4!7E37EG6@!34!?=6! 9ADD69?8P6!8;!?=6!RA>U!!"##$T!!2;@6>!?=6!@6F8;8?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>6!?RA!9AGMA;6;?7! 9>8?89:D!?A!8?7!E;@6>7?:;@8;<T!!$A>6GA7?!87!?=6!8@6:D!?=:?!8?!76?7!FA>?=T!!'=87!8@6:D! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! U3&2'$h!fJKKKhS!V"0'RQ$''*-V$+>4'!fJKKKhS!-:>:?>AAM6>!fJKKL\JKKYhS!:;@!W1$&1! fJKKYhT! ! L[! :MM6:>7!?A!AP6>9AG6!?=6!@8FF6>6;967!AF!8?7!78;<ED:>8?867!:;@!>6;@6>7!:!M>67EG6@! 8@6;?8?4!?=:?!87!=:>GA;8AE7D4!E;8F86@T!!$E>?=6>S!;A?8A;7!AF!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6! >6D:?8A;7=8M!8?!G:8;?:8;7!?A!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!R=AD6!D:4!E;@6>!?=6!EG3>6DD:!AF! 9AGGE;8?4T!!(;?>8;789!?A!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>6!?=676!?RA!AMMA78;<!9A;96M?7T!!! ! '>:@8?8A;:D!;A?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!MD:96!GA7?S!8F!;A?!:DDS!6GM=:787!A;!?=6! 9ADD69?8P8?4!AF!8;@8P8@E:D7S!=AR6P6>S!P:DE6!GE7?!36!MD:96@!A;?A!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:7! GE?:3D6!:;@!8;@6F8;8?6!6;?8?867T!!'=6!M>A3D6G!R8?=!?>:@8?8A;:D!@6F8;8?8A;7!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!87!?=:?!?=64!:>6!67?:3D87=6@!8;!?6>G7!AF!:!E?AM89!8@6:DT!!'=6!8GMD898?! =AGA<6;6AE7!P878A;!AF!7A98:D!A>@6>!:DDE@67!?A!:!96>?:8;!E?AM8:;87GT!!'=6!;:?E>6!AF! ?=:?!E?AM89!P878A;!?=>AE<=!:!>6@E9?8P6!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!?A!8G:<8;6!:! E;8P6>7:D!98P8D8a:?8A;S!R=89=!87!8;9A;?>AP6>?83D4!;A?!MA7783D6T!!(;!A>@6>!?A!679:M6!:! E?AM8:;!<A:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!:!FA9E7!A;!8;@8P8@E:D!7E3_69?7!GE7?!36!MD:96@T!!! ! !"##$!9AGGE;89:?67!?=6!7D8MM6>4S!:;@!7AG6?8G67!9A;FD89?8;<S!;:?E>6!36?R66;! ?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!8;?A!?=6!3>A:@6>!9A;?6Q?!AF!?=6!:<<>6778P6! >6A><:;8a:?8A;!AF!9ED?E>:DS!7A98:DS!69A;AG89S!:;@!MAD8?89:D!D8F6!AF!MA7?GA@6>;8?4T!!N8?=! ?=6!@69>6:78;<!:P:8D:38D8?4!AF!7?:?6\FE;@6@!76>P8967!:;@!?=6!9ADD:M76!AF!P:>8AE7! R6DF:>6!747?6G7S!?=6!>6:D8?4!AF!7E9=!6Q87?6;?8:D!>67MA;7838D8?867!:7!=6:D?=9:>6!:;@! 7A98:D!769E>8?4!FA>!6Q:GMD6S!369AG6!8;9>6:78;<D4!:MM:>6;?!8;!?=6!9E>>6;?!MAD8?89:D! 9D8G:?6T!!'A!HE67?8A;!?=6!>6D:?8A;7=8M!36?R66;!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!:;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6! 369AG67!:!M6>?8;6;?!@879E778A;!:3AE?!3E>@6;!:;@!M6>7A;:D!>67MA;7838D8?4T!%8U6R876S! 8;!!"##$!?=6!F8<E>8;67!GE7?!7E7?:8;!?=68>!9ADD69?8P8?4!8;!A>@6>!?A!R8?=7?:;@!?=6!R68<=?! AF!?=A76!R=A!?>6:@!:3AP6!?=6GS!?=E7!8DDE7?>:?8;<!?=6!=6:P4!3E>@6;!AF!7A98:D! ! JK! >67MA;7838D8?4T!!'=68>!?8;4!MD:7?89!M:DG7!M>6776@!AP6>=6:@!>6G:8;!8;!MA78?8A;!FA>!?=6! 7AD6!ME>MA76!AF!>6787?8;<!368;<!9>E7=6@T! ! (;!,89=:6D!1:>@?!:;@!.;?A;8A!*6<>8`7!;0"5+50>'L-?1$-1*>-T'&#8$18<-+*-59'- 34'-#.-B&C+$'S!?=6!?=6A>8a:?8A;!AF!?=6!GED?8?E@6!87!M:>?89ED:>D4!E76FED!8;!?=6! @879E778A;!AF!0A!1A!+E=`7!RA>UT!'=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;!!"##$!9A>>67MA;@7!?A! 1:>@?!:;@!*6<>8`7!;A?8A;!AF!?=6!GED?8?E@6!R=6>6!?=6!RA>U!@87MD:47!:!>6DE9?:;96!?A! 9A;96@6!:;!AD@6>!F:;?:74!AF!:!9ADD69?8P6!3A@4!?=:?!FE;9?8A;7!:7!A;6T!'=6!7E3_69?7!@A! ;A?!9A=6>6!:7!:!E;8F86@!9ADD69?8P6!3A@4!369:E76!8?!87!;A?!MA76@!8;!AMMA78?8A;!?A!:! F8Q6@!F8<E>6!AF!@AG8;:?8A;T!$A>!1:>@?!:;@!*6<>8S!?=6!GED?8?E@6!87!:!M:>:@8<G!AF! 7E3_69?8P8?4!:;@!9ADD69?8P8?4!9A;7?>E9?6@!AF!?6GMA>:>4!:;@!8;9A;9DE78P6!>6D:?8A;7T! '=64!R>8?6S!c'=6!GED?8?E@6!87!9AGMA76@!AF!:!76?!AF!78;<ED:>8?867j:;@!34!78;<ED:>8?4! R6!G6:;!:!7A98:D!7E3_69?!R=A76!@8FF6>6;96!9:;;A?!36!>6@E96@!?A!7:G6;677S!:! @8FF6>6;96!?=:?!>6G:8;7!@8FF6>6;?Td LW !!(;!?=6!7:G6!R:4S!:?!F8>7?!<D:;96!?=6!F8<E>8;67!8;! !"##$!=:P6!?=6!:MM6:>:;96!AF!368;<!@EMD89:?67!AF!6:9=!A?=6>S!=AR6P6>S!8?!369AG67! :MM:>6;?!?=:?!?=64!:>6!8;!F:9?!G:D6!A>!F6G:D6S!>676G3D6!@8FF6>6;?!6?=;898?867S!:;@!:>6! @>6776@!8;@8P8@E:DD4!8;!:!9ADA>!7M69?>EG!?=:?!>:;<67!8;!7=:@67!AF!368<6S!9:G6DS!76M8:S! 3>AR;S!:;@!A:?G6:DT!!N6!9:;!6Q:G8;6!+E=`7!9ADD69?8P6!AF!F8<E>8;67!?=>AE<=!1:>@?! :;@!*6<>8`7!GA@6D!AF!?=6!GED?8?E@6!8;!?=:?!3A?=!6Q=838?!?=6!?6;78A;!?=:?!6Q87?7! 36?R66;!?=6!78;<ED:>!:;@!MDE>:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!'=6!GED?8?E@6!87!M:>:@AQ89:DD4!:?! A;96!A;6!:;@!G:;4T!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LW !,89=:6D!1:>@?!:;@!.;?A;8A!*6<>8S!;0"5+50>'L-?1$-1*>-T'&#8$18<-+*-59'-34'-#.- B&C+$'!f*6R!/A>UV!'=6!-6;<E8;!->677S!JKKZhS![[T! ! JL! '=6!:DDE>6!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!?=:?!8?!87!:3D6!?A!AM6>:?6!A;!GED?8MD6!D6P6D7T!(?!9:;! 36!AFF6>6@!:7!:;!A3_69?!AF!:MM6:76G6;?S!?:U6!?=6!FA>G!AF!:;!:MM6:DS!A>!FE;9?8A;!:7!:! @6G:;@T!'=676!P:>8AE7!9A;F8<E>:?8A;7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:DD!7?6G!F>AG!:!9A;96M?!AF! MAR6>!:;@!?=E7!=:P6!366;!:77A98:?6@!R8?=!96>?:8;!9>8?89:D!@879AE>767S!D8U6!,:>Q87GS! R=89=!766U!?A!8;?6>P6;6!8;!?=6!=6<6GA;89!9A;7?>E9?8A;!AF!:E?=A>8?4T!!'=6!?6>G! 9AGGE;87G!8;!,:>Q87?!@879AE>76!:9?7!:7!:!c9>8?89:D!@87>EM?8A;!AF!?=6!@AG8;:;?! G4?=7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!D6<8?8G:?6!?=6!G:8;?6;:;96!AF!:;!AMM>6778P6!747?6G!AF! @8FF6>6;967Td L[ !.99A>@8;<!?A!,:>Q87?!?>:@8?8A;S!8@6:7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>6!@6M89?6@!:7!:! <>AEM!E;8?6@!8;!9D:77!7?>E<<D6T!c.;!6Q:G8;:?8A;!AF!,:>Q87G!7EMMD867!E7!R8?=!:;! :99AE;?!AF!?=6!6G6><6;96!AF!?=6!G4?=!AF!9AGGE;8?4!R=6>634!?=6!G6:;7!AF! M>A@E9?8A;!M>AP8@6!:;!69A;AG89!3:76S!R=89=!@6?6>G8;67!?=6!D:><6>!7A98:DS!MAD8?89:DS! :;@!8@6ADA<89:D!:MM:>:?8T!! 56:;\%E9!*:;94!AFF6>7!:!9>8?8HE6!AF!3A?=!6776;?8:D87?!:;@!,:>Q87?!8@6:7!AF! 9AGGE;8?867!8;!=87!677:4S!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<T!!16!9:DD7!FA>!?=6!>69A<;8?8A;!AF! GED?8MD6!PA8967!R8?=8;!:!9AGGE;8?4T!!187!;A?8A;!AF!:;!c8;AM6>:?8P6!9AGGE;8?4d!87! ;68?=6>!:!9AGGE;8?4!AF!7E3_69?7!;A>!8;@8P8@E:D7!76>P8;<!E;@6>!:!=8<=6>!A>!<>6:?6>! ?A?:D8?4T!!'=6!:376;96!AF!:!G6?:M=4789:D!F8<E>6S!FA>!6Q:GMD6S!:!cF:?=6>D:;@S!c!87! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! L[ !%8;@:!+8;<6>S!c"69:DD8;<!:!&AGGE;8?4!:?!%AA76!#;@7Sd!8;!@#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,S! 6@T!'=6!,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87! ->677S!L[[LhS!LJ^T! ! ! JJ! 6776;?8:D!?A!?=6!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:!7A98:D!A><:;8a:?8A;!9A;7?8?E?6@!34!?=6! 9A6Q87?6;96!AF!78;<ED:>8?4T !JK !*:;94!D:?6>!R>8?67S!! '=6!78;<ED:>!368;<!87!;68?=6>!?=6!9AGGA;!368;<!;A>!?=6!8;@8P8@E:DT!!'=6>6!87!:! 9A;96M?!AF!?=6!9AGGA;!368;<!:;@!AF!?=6!8;@8P8@E:Di!?=6>6!87!<6;6>:D8?4!AF! R=:?!87!9AGGA;!:;@!AF!?=6!8;@8P8@E:DT!!'=6>6!87!;68?=6>!AF!?=676!FA>!?=6! 78;<ED:>!368;<T!!'=6>6!87!;A?!78;<ED:>!2'+*4V!?=6>6!87S!:;@!?=87!87!@8FF6>6;?S!:;! 6776;?8:D!78;<ED:>8?4!#.-2'+*4!8?76DF!f8?7!F8;8?E@6S!8;!168@6<<6>`7!D:;<E:<6hT!! '=:?!87!?A!7:4S!?=6!c78;<ED:>!368;<d!87!;A?!:!U8;@!AF!368;<!:GA;<!368;<7T JL !!!! ! *:;94!:9U;ARD6@<67!:!@8FF6>6;?8:?8A;!36?R66;!7E3_69?7!:7!78;<ED:>8?867!:;@!?=6! ;A?8A;!AF!?=6!9ADD69?8P6T!!(;!!"##$S!?=6!@4;:G89!36?R66;!?=676!?RA!9A;96M?7!>6G:8;!8;! 9A;7?:;?!9A;FD89?!R8?=!6:9=!A?=6>T!'=6!@6F8;8?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!D:9U7!:!@6F8;8?8P6! :E?=A>8a8;<!FAE;@:?8A;!369:E76!8?!6;9AGM:7767!AMMA78;<!9A;96M?7!AF!?=6!78;<ED:>8?4! :;@!?=6!9ADD69?8P6S!46?!8?!87!:DR:47!:D>6:@4!78?E:?6@!8;!7A98:DS!MAD8?89:DS!9ED?E>:DS!:;@! 8;7?8?E?8A;:D!7M=6>67T!!+?>:;<6D4S!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87!:3D6!?A!3A?=!7EFF6>!F>AG! :;@!36!FA>?8F86@!34!:!96>?:8;!P:<E6;677T!!! '=6!@8FF89ED?!?:7U!AF!>6@8>69?8;<!?=6!8@6:D!AF!9AGGE;8?4!>6HE8>67!:!G:_A>! >6A><:;8a:?8A;!AF!?=6!9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!);6!GE7?!GAP6!:R:4!F>AG!?=6! M6>96M?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:;!6Q87?8;<!7A98:D!FA>G:?8A;!:;@!9A;78@6>!?=6!8@6:!AF!:! GED?8?E@6!AF!78;<ED:>8?867!?=:?!9A6Q87?!R8?=!A;6!:;A?=6>T!!(;!?=87!R:4S!:!GA>6!FDE8@! 9A;96M?!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!:M:>?!F>AG!:!=AGA<6;6AE7!P878A;!AF!7A98:D!A><:;8a:?8A;S! G:U67!8?!MA7783D6!FA>!;6R!8@6:7!AF!9A6Q87?6;96!?A!@6P6DAMT! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JK !56:;\%E9!*:;94S!c'=6!(;AM6>:?8P6!&AGGE;8?4Sd!8;!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!6@T! -6?6>!&A;;A>!f,8;;6:MAD87g%A;@A;V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!JX\JWT! JL !56:;\%E9!*:;94S!c%8?6>:>4!&AGGE;87GSd!8;!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!6@T!-6?6>! &A;;A>!f,8;;6:MAD87g%A;@A;V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!XXT! ! JY! &1.-'#"!YV!&AGGE;8?4!:;@!16?6>A<6;68?4! ! (;!N:D?6>!I6;_:G8;`7!677:4!E9'-?#$X-#.-3$5-+*-59'-34'-#.-;'891*+81"- ='C$#>085+#*S!=6!@6F8;67!:E>:!:7!c?=6!E;8HE6!M=6;AG6;:!AF!:!@87?:;96S!=AR6P6>! 9DA76!8?!G:4!36Td JJ !16!:><E67!?=:?!:E>:!87!G6@8:?6@!34!7M:96!:;@!=EG:;!76;76! M6>96M?8A;S!R=89=!?=6!D:??6>!87!@89?:?6@!34!?=6!@678>6!?A!c3>8;<!?=8;<7!n9DA76>`! 7M:?8:DD4!:;@!=EG:;D4e?AR:>@!AP6>9AG8;<!?=6!E;8HE6;677!AF!6P6>4!>6:D8?4!34! :996M?8;<!8?7!>6M>A@E9?8A;Td JY !I6;_:G8;`7!9>8?8HE6!AF!?=6!F86D@!AF!M6>96M?8A;!87! M:>?89ED:>D4!9AGM6DD8;<!8;!=87!@879E778A;!AF!=AR!;6R!?69=;ADA<89:D!M=6;AG6;:S!D8U6! F8DG!:;@!M=A?A<>:M=4S!=:7!;A?!A;D4!8GM:9?6@!c=EG:;8?4`7!GA@6!AF!6Q87?6;96Sd!3E?! =:7!:D7A!7=8F?6@!=EG:;8?4`7!GA@6!AF!M6>96M?8A;T!!'=6!@87?8;9?8A;!36?R66;!cM89?E>6! G:<:a8;67!:;@!;6R7>66Dd!:;@!c?=6!8G:<6!766;!34!?=6!E;:>G6@!646d!87!367?! E;@6>7?AA@!8;!?6>G7!AF!?6;78A;!:;@!A798DD:?8A;T!!16!R>8?67S!! 'A!M>4!:;!A3_69?!F>AG!8?7!7=6DDS!?A!@67?>A4!8?7!:E>:S!87!?=6!G:>U!AF!:!M6>96M?8A;! R=A76!c76;76!AF!?=6!E;8P6>7:D!6HE:D8?4!AF!?=8;<7d!=:7!8;9>6:76@!?A!7E9=!:! @6<>66!?=:?!8?!6Q?>:9?7!8?!6P6;!F>AG!:!E;8HE6!A3_69?!34!G6:;7!AF! >6M>A@E9?8A;e'=6!:@_E7?G6;?!AF!:!>6:D8?4!?A!?=6!G:7767!:;@!AF!?=6!G:7767!?A! >6:D8?4!87!:!M>A9677!AF!E;D8G8?6@!79AM6S!:7!GE9=!FA>!?=8;U8;<!:7!FA>! M6>96M?8A;T JZ !! ! '=6!M:77:<6!?=>AE<=!1:6<E6!/:;<`7!8;7?:DD:?8A;!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'- 3$$1*4'&'*5,!36:>7!I6;_:G8;`7!:;:D4787!AF!M6>96M?8A;!:;@!:E>:S!R=89=!@87MD:47! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JJ !N:D?6>!I6;_:G8;S!E9'-?#$X-#.-3$5-+*-59'-34'-#.-;'891*+81"-='C$#>085+#*!f*6R! /A>UV!&>6:?6+M:96S!JKLKhS!LXT! ! JY !(38@T! ! JZ !(38@T! ! JZ! 3A?=!:!7M:?8:D!:;@!?6GMA>:D!@8G6;78A;!AF!@87?:;96T!'=6!RA>U!9A;787?7!AF!:;! :>>:;<6G6;?!AF!@AG67?89!@6P8967!8;9DE@8;<!D8<=?7S!6D69?>A;89!F:;7S!8;F>:>6@!=6:?6>7S! =EG8@8F86>7S!:;@!:?AG8a6>7!?=:?!9ADD69?8P6D4!9>6:?6!:!GED?8\76;7A>4!6;P8>A;G6;?T!! #:9=!@6P896!9D:8G7!8?7!AR;!76;7A>8:D!?6>>8?A>4!8;!R=89=!HE:D8?867!AF!=6:?S!7G6DDS! DEG8;A78?4S!:;@!9AAD;677!79:??6>!?=>AE<=AE?!:;!8;7?:DD:?8A;!7M:96T!!C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7! FA>G!8;@87?8;9?!8;?6>8A>7!:;@!6Q?6>8A>7!R=6>6!@8P6>76!796;?7!f6T<TS!F>67=!D:E;@>4S!<E;! MAR@6>S!9AFF66!7=AMS!@8;A7:E>!@E;<S!F>67=!9E?!<>:77S!6?9h!:;@!3>66a67!AF!@8FF6>8;<! ?6GM6>:?E>67!:>6!:3D6!?A!?>:P6D!AP6>!?A!A?=6>!76;7A>8:D!aA;67T!!'=6!3D8;@7!:D7A!76>P6! ?A!A><:;8a6!?=6!7M:96!9>6:?8;<!3A>@6>7S!7M:?8:D!96DD7S!:;@!M:?=R:47!FA>!P878?A>7!?A! R:DU!?=>AE<=T!!'=6!GAP6G6;?!AF!:!P878?A>!87!6;<8;66>6@!?A!?>8<<6>!@6P8967!?A!?E>;!A;! :;@!AFF!:?!P:>8AE7!8;?6>P:D7!7A!?=:?!A;6!E;@6><A67!:!76HE6;96!AF!M=4789:D! M=6;AG6;:!:?!:;!8;@8P8@E:D!M:96!P8:!:!>AE?6!?=:?!87!9AGMD6?6D4!@87?8;9?!F>AG!>AE?67! AF!A?=6>!P86R6>7T!'=676!A3_69?7S!=:P8;<!;A!M:>?89ED:>!>6D:?8A;!?A!A;6!:;A?=6>S!:>6! :>>:;<6@!:7!:!<>AEM!AF!G87MD:96@!:;@!8;9A;<>EAE7!A3_69?7T!'=64!:>6S!=AR6P6>S!:DD! 9A;;69?6@!34!:;!8;?>89:?6!;6?RA>U!AF!R8>67!?=:?!7=:>6!:!78;<D6!MAR6>!7AE>96T! C878?A>7!:>6!6QMA76@!?A!76;7A>4!6QM6>86;967!?=:?!D8;U!?=6!9ADD69?8P6!3:9U!?A!?=6! 8;@8P8@E:D!?=>AE<=!@87?8;9?!:77A98:?8A;7!M>AGM?6@!34!6:9=!6;9AE;?6>T!'=6!JKK^! 6Q=838?8A;!7*'G'*"<!:?!I.BS!3:787!PAA>!:9?E6D6!BE;7?!8;!2?>69=?!R:7!?=6!F8>7?!?8G6! %'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,!R:7!ME?!A;!@87MD:4T!!(?!=:7!78;96!E;@6><A;6! 76P6>:D!8?6>:?8A;7!8;!7E9=!8;7?8?E?8A;7!:7!?=6!N:DU6>!.>?!&6;?6>!8;!,8;;6:MAD87S! "#0&.'!8;!%A7!.;<6D67S!:;@!?=6!JKK[!C6;896!I86;;:D6T!! ! J]! '=6!6QM6>86;96!AF!R:DU8;<!?=>AE<=!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,!87! 9=:><6@!R8?=!96>63>:D!9A;?:9?!:;@!M=4789:D!8;?8G:94!R8?=!?=6!7M:96T!!'=6!:E>:?89! HE:D8?4!AF!?=6!RA>U!AM6>:?67!:74GG6?>89:DD4i!?=6!I6;_:G8;8:;!;A?8A;!AF!:E>:!>67?7! A;!?=6!F86D@!AF!M6>96M?8A;!?=:?!6Q87?7!7E>>AE;@8;<!?=6!$'C$#>085+#*!AF!:;!8G:<6S! R=8D6!/:;<!766G8;<D4!6;<:<67!M6>96M?8A;!?=>AE<=!?=6!12,5$185+#*!AF!:;!8G:<6T!!(;! ?=87!R:4S!A3_69?7!?=:?!:>6!9AGMD6?6D4!GE;@:;6!:;@!3:;:D!:>6!FEDD!AF!MA6?89! MA77838D8?4\!:;!cE;D8G8?6@!79AM6d!FA>!M6>96M?8A;T! (?!87!U64!?A!>69A<;8a6!?=:?!/:;<`7!FA>G:D!E76!AF!:37?>:9?8A;!6;<:<67! M6>96M?8A;!8;!:!R:4!?=:?!:DDAR7!FA>!8;@8P8@E:D!:77A98:?8A;7!:;@!9A;;A?:?8A;7!?A! E;FAD@!6;@D677D4T!'=6!MA?6;?8:D!FA>!8;@8P8@E:D7!R=A!6QM6>86;96!?=6!7:G6!M=4789:D! M=6;AG6;:!?A!36!FE;@:G6;?:DD4!@87?8;9?!F>AG!A;6!:;A?=6>!34!?=6!=6?6>A<6;68?4!AF! ?=68>!AR;!7AG:?89!M6>96M?8A;7!87!8;?6<>:D!?A!/:;<`7!6QMDA>:?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;!=6>! RA>UT!!1:6<E6!/:;<`7!M>:9?896!9A;787?7!AF!6;P8>A;G6;?7!:;@!79EDM?E>67!?=:?!MA77677! :!;:>>:?8P6!A?=6>!?=:;!R=:?!87!8GG6@8:?6D4!P8783D6T!!'=6!6P6>4@:4!A3_69?7!7=6! 6GMDA47!M6>FA>G!:!D:><6>!>AD6!364A;@!?=68>!E?8D8?:>8:;!FE;9?8A;7T!-:>?89ED:>D4!8;!?=6! M8696!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,O!?=64!:>6!<:?=6>6@!:;@!c:>>:;<6@d!?A!FA>G! ;6R!78?E:?8A;7!?=:?!AM6;!EM!:!7M:96!AF!MA?6;?8:D8?4T!!)>@8;:>4!:;@!GE;@:;6!A3_69?7! :>6!@6D836>:?6D4!MDE9U6@!F>AG!?=68>!;A>G:?8P6!9A;?6Q?7!:;@!>6MA78?8A;6@!8;!7D8<=?D4! A@@!R:47T!!/:;<!@6P8767!E;F:G8D8:>!?6>>8?A>867!?=:?!7=6!@679>8367!:7!c>:?=6>! ! J^! 8G:<8;:>4j;A?!E?AM8:;jA;6S!:;@!DA9:?6@!AE?78@6!AF!@6?69?:3D6!:;@!P8783D6! ?6>>8?A>4S!G:436!7AG6R=6>6!8;!G4!G8;@Td J] !! '=87!>6FD69?7!I6;6@89?!.;@6>7A;`7!:MM>AM>8:?6D4!?8?D6@!3AAU!F&14+*'>- @#&&0*+5+',-fL[WYhO!R=89=!@679>8367!9AGGE;8?4!:7!:;!8G:<8;6@!7M:96T!16!R>8?67S!! (?!87!8G:<8;6@!369:E76!?=6!G6G36>7!AF!6P6;!?=6!7G:DD67?!;:?8A;!R8DD!;6P6>! U;AR!GA7?!AF!?=68>!F6DDAR!G6G36>7S!G66?!?=6GS!A>!6P6;!=6:>!AF!?=6GS!46?!8;! ?=6!G8;@7!AF!6:9=!D8P67!?=6!8G:<6!AF!?=68>!9AGGE;8A;e(;!F:9?S!:DD! 9AGGE;8?867!D:><6>!?=:;!M>8GA>@8:D!P8DD:<67!AF!F:96\?A\F:96!9A;?:9?!f:;@! M6>=:M7!6P6;!?=676h!:>6!8G:<8;6@T!!&AGGE;8?867!:>6!?A!36!@87?8;<E87=6@S!;A?! 34!?=68>!F:D78?4g<6;E8;6;677S!3E?!34!?=6!7?4D6!8;!R=89=!?=64!:>6!8G:<8;6@T J^ !! ! N6!GE7?!HE67?8A;S!?=6;S!34!R=:?!7?4D6!@A67!/:;<!8G:<8;6!=6>!9AGGE;8?4b!(;!:!JKK^! 8;?6>P86R!36?R66;!?=6!:>?87?!:;@!9E>:?A>!I8;;:!&=A8!FA>!?=6!6Q=838?8A;!7*'G'*"<S! /:;<!@879E7767!?=6!76:>9=!FA>!:!9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!87!:3D6!?A!cAP6>9AG6!?=6!78GMD6! @87?8;9?8A;!36?R66;!?=87!9AGGE;8?4!:;@!?=:?S!A>!36?R66;!:!n=AG6`!:;@!n;A!=AG6T`d JX ! +=6!;A?67S!c(!RAED@!9:DD!8?!:!n9AGGE;8?4!AF!:376;96S`!FADDAR8;<!l$>6;9=!R>8?6>! O6A><6m!I:?:8DD6S!n:!9AGGE;8?4!AF!?=A76!R=A!@A!;A?!=:P6!:!9AGGE;8?4T`d JW !! (;!?=6!?6Q?!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<!56:;\%E9!*:;94S!R=A!3E8D@7!=87! R>8?8;<7!A;!I:?:8DD6S!69=A67!?=87!;A?8A;!AF!:!9AGGE;8?4!AF!?=A76!R=A!@A!;A?!=:P6!:! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! J] !I8;;:!&=A8!:;@!1:6<E6!/:;<S!c&AGGE;8?4!AF!.376;96V!&A;P6>7:?8A;!R8?=!1:6<E6! /:;<Sd!8;!7*'G'*"<S!*6R7D6??6>!JKK^!oJ!f2?>69=?V!I.BS!3:787!PAA>!:9?E6D6!BE;7?S! JKK^hS!LYT! J^ !I6;6@89?!.;@6>7A;S!F&14+*'>-@#&&0*+5+',L-='."'85+#*,-#*-59'-)$+4+*-1*>-%C$'1>-#.- Y15+#*1"+,&!f%A;@A;g*6R!/A>UV!C6>7AS!L[WYh!^T! ! JX !I8;;:!&=A8!:;@!1:6<E6!/:;<S!c&AGGE;8?4!AF!.376;96V!&A;P6>7:?8A;!R8?=!1:6<E6! /:;<Sd!8;!7*'G'*"<S!*6R7D6??6>!JKK^!oJ!f2?>69=?V!I.BS!3:787!PAA>!:9?E6D6!BE;7?S! JKK^hS!LYT! ! JW !(38@T! ! ! JX! 9AGGE;8?4T!!16!R>8?67S!c&AGGE;8?4!87!R=:?!?:U67!MD:96!:DR:47!?=>AE<=!A?=6>7!:;@! FA>!A?=6>7Td J[ !!c(?!87!;A?Sd!=6!9A;?8;E67S!c?=6!7M:96!AF!?=6!6<A7j7E3_69?7!:;@! 7E37?:;967!?=:?!:>6!:?!3A??AG!8GGA>?:Dj3E?!AF!?=6!(`7S!R=A!:>6!:DR:47!A?=6>7!fA>! 6D76!:>6!;A?=8;<he(?!87!;A?!:!9AGGE;8A;!?=:?!FE767!?=6!6<A7!8;?A!:;!#<A!A>!:!=8<=6>! N6T!(?!87!?=6!9AGGE;8?4!AF!A?=6>7Td YK !/:;<!3>8;<7!?A!36:>!*:;94`7!;A?8A;!AF!:! 9AGGE;8?4!AF!A?=6>7!8;!=6>!76:>9=!FA>!:!9AGGE;8?4!AF!?=A76!R=A!@A!;A?!=:P6!:! 9AGGE;8?4!?=>AE<=!?=6!9A;96M?E:D8a:?8A;!AF!?=6!cA?=6>d!8;!=6>!RA>UT!!(;!%'$+',-#.- /0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,S!?=6!U8;@!AF!9AGGE;:D!7M:96!7=6!9A;7?>E9?7!87!>:?=6>! F>:<G6;?6@S!R=6>6!P878?A>7!A376>P6!?=6!@87?:;96!36?R66;!A;676DF!:;@!?=6!A><:;8a8;<! 7A98:D!7?>E9?E>6!AF!A3_69?7!?=:?!=:P6!;A!M:>?89ED:>!>6D:?8A;!?A!A;6!:;A?=6>T!!C878?A>7! :>6!:?!A;96!>6P6:D6@!?A!36!7A98:D!368;<7!34!?=6!7AD6!F:9?!?=:?!?=64!8;=:38?!?=6! 8;7?:DD:?8A;!7M:96S!46?!:D7A!369AG6!cA?=6>7Sd!A99:78A;:DD4!=8@@6;!34!3D8;@7!?=:?!:9?!:7! 3A?=!3:>>86>S!:7!R6DD!:7!M6>G6:3D6!@8P8@6T!'=6!=:DF\?>:;7M:>6;?!HE:D8?4!AF!?=6! C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7!78GED?:;6AE7D4!9>6:?67!8;78@6!:;@!AE?78@6!7M:96S!=AR6P6>!?=6! @8P878A;!>6G:8;7!:G38<EAE7T!'=64!GA>6!7A!9>6:?6!:;!AM6;!7?>E9?E>6!R=6>6!?=6! @6G:>9:?8A;!36?R66;!8;?6>8A>!:;@!6Q?6>8A>!87!8;@87?8;9?S!R=6>6!A;6`7!MA78?8A;:D8?4! >6G:8;7!8;!:!7?:?6!AF!FDE8@8?4T! $A>!*:;94S!R6!:>6!:D>6:@4!3AE;@!?A!A;6!:;A?=6>S!A>!cA?=6>7Sd!AR8;<!?A!:;! cA>8<8;:D!A>!A;?ADA<89:D!n7A98:D8?4`!?=:?e6Q?6;@7!F:>!364A;@!?=6!78GMD6!?=6G6!AF!G:;! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! J[ !56:;\%E9!*:;94S!c'=6!(;AM6>:?8P6!&AGGE;8?4Sd!8;!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<S!6@T! -6?6>!&A;;A>!f,8;;6:MAD87g%A;@A;V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhS!L]T! YK !(38@T! ! ! JW! :7!:!7A98:D!368;<Td YL !*A>G:?8P6!GA@6D7!AF!9AGGE;8?4!:>6!FAE;@6@!A;!?=6!8@6:!AF!:! 9ADD69?8P6!3A@4!9AGM>876@!AF!9A=6>6;?!:;@!E;8F86@!7A98:D!7E3_69?7T!*:;94S!=AR6P6>S! 96;?6>7!9AGGE;8?4!A;!?=6!8@6:!?=:?!8;@8P8@E:D!8@6;?8?4!87!8;!:!9A;7?:;?!7?:?6!AF!FDEQ! :;@!;6<A?8:?8A;!?=>AE<=!6;9AE;?6>7!R8?=!A?=6>7T!!*:;94`7!9AGGE;8?4!AF!A?=6>7!87! :>?89ED:?6@!?=>AE<=!:!@879E778A;!AF!@6:?=S!R=89=S!:99A>@8;<!?A!=8GS!G:>U7!?=6! 78;<ED:>8?867!AF!AE>!368;<T!!16!R>8?67S!c'=6!FEDD4!>6:D8a6@!M6>7A;!AF!8;@8P8@E:D87?89!A>! 9AGGE;87?89!=EG:;87G!87!?=6!@6:@!M6>7A;Td YJ !&AGGE;8?4S!:7!*:;94!R:;?7!?A!>6P8P6! ?=6!;A?8A;S!87!@6F8;6@!34!7AG6?=8;<!R6!:DD!7=:>6!:;@!46?!9:;;A?!9AGGE;89:?6V!@6:?=T!! 16!9A;?8;E67S!c&AGGE;8?4!87!9:D83>:?6@!A;!@6:?=!:7!A;!?=:?!AF!R=89=!8?!87!M>69876D4! 8GMA7783D6!?A!G:U6!:!RA>U!fA?=6>!?=:;!:!RA>U!AF!@6:?=S!:7!7AA;!:7!A;6!?>867!?A!G:U6! :!RA>U!AF!8?hT!&AGGE;8?4!A99E>7!8;!A>@6>!?A!:9U;ARD6@<6!?=87!8GMA77838D8?4Td YY !! 06:?=!87!:;!6QM6>86;96!?=:?!9AGGE;8?4!87!E;:3D6!?A!9D:8G!8;!?=6!76;76!?=:?!8?! M>676;?7!:!>:@8:D!G6:;8;<D677;677!?=:?!9:;;A?!36!?>:;796;@6@!A>!7E37EG6@T!!(?!87! ?=6!?=8;<!GA7?!FA>68<;!?A!G:;U8;@T!.D?=AE<=!:!7A986?4!G:4!P6>4!R6DD!E76!8?!?=>AE<=! 96>6GA;8:D!>8?E:D7!AF!@6:?=!?A!8;?8G:?6!:!G:>U!AF!E;8P6>7:D8?4S!=AR6P6>S!@6:?=! ED?8G:?6D4!6QMA767!E7!?A!AE>!AR;!F8;8?E@6T!!(?!E;9AP6>7!?=6!8GMA77838D8?4!AF! 9AGGE;:D!D8F6!369:E76!9AGGE;8?4!@A67!;A?S!:;@!9:;;A?!AM6>:?6!8;!@6:?=j?=6>6!87! ;A!9AGGE;8A;!A>!8GG:;6;96!36FA>6!?=6!@6:@!A?=6>T!!*:;94!R>8?67S!c&AGGE;8?4!87! >6P6:D6@!8;!?=6!@6:?=!AF!A?=6>7e8?!:77EG67!?=6!8GMA77838D8?4!AF!8?7!AR;!8GG:;6;96S! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YL !(38@TS!JWT! YJ !(38@TS!LYT! ! YY !(38@TS!L]T! ! ! J[! ?=6!8GMA77838D8?4!AF!:!9AGGE?:>8:;!368;<!8;!?=6!FA>G!AF!:!7E3_69?T!!(;!:!96>?:8;!76;76S! 9AGGE;8?4!:9U;ARD6@<67!:;@!8;79>8367j?=87!87!8?7!M69ED8:>!<67?E>6j?=6! 8GMA77838D8?4!AF!9AGGE;8?4Td YZ !! (?!87!?=87!8GMA77838D8?4!AF!9AGGE;8?4!?=:?!1:6<E6!/:;<`7!RA>U!7A! 9AGM6DD8;<D4!9A;P647T!!OA8;<!3:9U!?A!56:;\%E9!*:;94S!9AGGE;8?4!87!9=:>:9?6>8a6@! 34S!c8?7!8;787?6;?!:;@!7?8DD!E;=6:>@!@6G:;@Sd!FA>!8?76DFT Y] !(?!87!7AG6?=8;<!?=:?!87!:DR:47! 6;<:<6@!8;!:;!E;F8;87=6@!RA>U8;<!AF!8?7!AR;!8@6;?8?4S!?=6!cHE67?8A;S!R:8?8;<S!6P6;?S! 8GM6>:?8P6j!8;!?=6!R:U6!AF!7A986?4Td Y^ !*:;94`7!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4!87! :>?89ED:?6@!?=>AE<=!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!E;RA>U8;<S!R=:?!=6!:D7A!9:DD7!8;AM6>:38D8?4S!A>!?=6! >Z,#0G$12"'T!'=6!E;RA>U8;<S!A>!8;AM6>:?8P6S!9AGGE;8?4!@A67!;A?!>6:D8a6!8?76DF!:7!:! M>A_69?!A>!RA>US!3E?!>:?=6>!:7!?=6!78<;8F86>!AF!?=6!8GMA77838D8?4!AF!9AGGE;8A;!A>! 8GG:;6;96!AF!AE>!F>:<8D6S!F8;8?6S!78;<ED:>!76DP67T!! (;!?=6!7:G6!R:4S!/:;<!9>6:?67!7M:967!R=6>6!9AGGE;8?4!87!;A?!9A;7?8?E?6@!34! 76DF\8@6;?89:D!7E3_69?7!9AG8;<!8;?A!9AGGE;8A;!34!:!9ADD69?8P6!6776;96!A>! 8GG:;6;96i!8;7?6:@S!FA>!/:;<!9AGGE;8?4!>67?7!A;!?=6!=6?6>A<6;68?4!AF!?=6! 8;@8P8@E:D!6QM6>86;96T!!+=6!6;E;98:?67!?=6!F>:<8D8?4!AF!?=6!78;<ED:>!76DF!?=>AE<=! :37?>:9?8A;!:;@!76;7A>8:D!6;<:<6G6;?!M>A@E96@!34!?=6!>69A;?6Q?E:D8a:?8A;!AF! @AG67?89!A3_69?7T!!'=6!E76!AF!@AG67?89!A3_69?7!G:U67!?=6!6QM6>86;96!AF!=6>!RA>U! P6>4!@6GA9>:?89!8;!?=6!76;76!?=:?!7E9=!A3_69?7!:7!F:;7!:;@!D8<=?7!=:P6!P6>4!D8??D6! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YZ !(38@T! ! Y] !(38@TS!JJT! ! Y^ !(38@TS!LLT! ! YK! 7A98:D!78<;8F89:;96!:;@!:MM6:D!GA>6!?A!?=6!76;767T!!16>!RA>U!:DDAR7!AE>!76;767!?A! @89?:?6!6QM6>86;96S!>:?=6>!?=:;!=86>:>9=867!AF!MAR6>S!M>8P8D6<6S!U;ARD6@<6S!6?9T!'=6! A3_69?7!:>6!;68?=6>!67M698:DD4!7E<<67?8P6!;A>!@A!?=64!7EMMA>?!:;4!M:>?89ED:>! >6F6>6;967!A>!:DDE78A;7T!!'=64!FE;9?8A;!:7!7?:;@:>@!@6P8967!A;6!RAED@!=:P6!:?!=AG6! A>!RA>US!9AGMD6?6D4!M6>8M=6>:D!:;@!GE;@:;6T!!1AR6P6>S!?=676!A3_69?7S!?=:?!R6>6! A;96!A>@8;:>4S!:>6!D836>:?6@!F>AG!?=68>!FE;9?8A;:D!9A;?6Q?7!:;@!;AR!FEDD!AF! M6>96M?E:D!MA77838D8?867T!!I4!G6:;7!AF!:>?87?89!?>:;7F6>S!?=6!:37?>:9?8A;!AF!/:;<`7!F:;7S! =6:?6>7S!796;?!6G8??6>7S!:;@!C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7!AM6;!EM!;6R!9A;@8?8A;7!FA>!M6>96M?8A;! :;@!6QM6>86;96T!! $A>!/:;<S!?=6!M:>?89ED:>!FA9E7!A;!?=6!6;<:<6G6;?!AF!?=6!8;@8P8@E:D!M6>96M?8A;! 87!:!9>8?89:D!9AGMA;6;?!?A!?=6!6QMDA>:?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!8;!=6>!RA>UT!!(?!87!?=>AE<=! @87?8;9?!8;@8P8@E:D!M6>96M?8A;!?=:?!MA8;?7!?A!?=6!8GMA77838D8?4!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!(;! %'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,!?=6>6!87!;A!:9?E:D!9ADD69?8P6!6QM6>86;96!:M:>?!F>AG! ?=6!F:9?!?=:?!P878?A>7!A99EM4!?=6!7:G6!8;7?:DD:?8A;!7M:96T!!'=6!7M698F89!9A;;A?:?8A;7! :;@!:77A98:?8A;7!<6;6>:?6@!34!?=6!6;9AE;?6>!AF!?=6!76;7A>8:D!6;P8>A;G6;?!:>6! M>69876D4!:;@!8;9A;?>AP6>?83D4!E;8HE6!?A!6:9=!P878?A>T!!N=:?!87!6QM6>86;96@!:7!R:>GS! 9AADS!F>:<>:;?S!A>!F6?8@!87!?A?:DD4!@6?6>G8;6@!34!A;6`7!AR;!7E3_69?8P8?4T!!'=6!@6DE78A;! AF!:!E;8F86@!9ADD69?8P6!FA>G6@!34!?=6!7E3G6><6;96!AF!@8FF6>6;96!87!>6MD:96@!34!?=6! >6:D8?4!AF!AE>!=6?6>A<6;6AE7!76DP67T!!'=6!R:4!8;!R=89=!1:6<E6!/:;<!9A;968P67! 9AGGE;8?4!8;!=6>!RA>U!87!?=>AE<=!?=6!R8?=@>:R:D!AF!:;!:FF8>G:?8A;!AF!:!7=:>6@! 6776;96!?=:?!MD:<E67!7A!G:;4!9AGGE;8?4\3:76@!:>?!M>A_69?7T!!+=6!9>6:?67!RA>U!?=:?! _EQ?:MA767!:!=6?6>A<6;68?4!A>!@8776;78A;!?A!9A;P6;?8A;:D!GA@6D7!AF!9AGGE;8?4T!!! ! YL! &)*&%2+()*! ! (;!?=87!?=6787!(!=:P6!9A;96;?>:?6@!A;!?=6!:??6GM?!?A!>6@8>69?!:!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!?AR:>@7!:!=6?6>A<6;6AE7!E;@6>7?:;@8;<!AF!7A98:D!FA>G:?8A;T!!,E9=!D8U6! ?=6!M:>?89ED:>!=6?6>A<6;6AE7!HE:D8?867!AF!:!MD:96S!36!8?!MAD8?89:DS!7A98:DS!9ED?E>:DS!A>! =87?A>89S!?=6!;A?8A;!AF!9AGGE;8?4!GE7?!:D7A!36!:MMD86@!?A!:!9AGM:>:3D6!7?:;@:>@T!! "6FD69?8A;7!A;!?=6!FA>G:?8A;!AF!:!ME3D89!7M:96!=:P6!DA;<!366;!8;!:!9A;?8;E:D!7?:?6!AF! FDEQT!!$>AG!?=6!9A;96M?!AF!:!I6;_:G8;8:;!ME3D89!7M:96!AF!7M:?8:D8a6@!7E3_69?8P8?867! @89?:?6@!34!9AGGA@8?4!9ED?E>6 YX !?A!5E><6;!1:36>G:7`!G6?=A@89:D!AE?D8;6!AF!M>8P:?6! M6AMD6!_A8;8;<!?A!FA>G!:!ME3D89!n7M=6>6T`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f&:G3>8@<6V!I6DU;:M!->677!AF!1:>P:>@! 2;8P6>78?4!->677S!JKKJhT! ! YW !5E><6;!1:36>G:7S!E9'-%5$0850$1"-E$1*,.#$&15+#*-#.-59'-H02"+8-%C9'$'L-3*-F*P0+$<- +*5#-1-@15'4#$<-#.-V#0$4'#+,-%#8+'5<!f&:G3>8@<6V!'=6!,('!->677S!L[[LhT! ! Y[ !.;?=A;4!C8@D6>S!?1$C'>-%C18'L-3$5O-3$89+5'850$'O-1*>-3*[+'5<-+*-;#>'$*-@0"50$'! f&:G3>8@<6V!'=6!,('!->677S!JKKKhT! ! YJ! 9A;78@6>7!:!ME3D89!7M:96!R=6>6!@8FF6>6;?!46?!M:>:DD6D!8;?6>67?7!9ADD8@6!8;! 8>>69A;98D:3D6!>6D:?8A;7=8M7T ZK !! '=6!HE67?8A;!AF!=AR!?A!>6?=8;US!>6@8>69?S!:;@!>6?=8;U!?=6!;A?8A;!AF! 9AGGE;8?4!87!:7!78<;8F89:;?!:7!?=6!7?>E<<D6!?A!@6F8;6!?6>G7!D8U6!cME3D89!:>?Sd!cME3D89! 7M:96Sd!:;@!c?=6!ME3D89Td!I4!R=:?!9>8?6>8:!@A67!A;6!6GMDA4!?A!@6F8;6!?6>G7!?=:?!:>6! 8;=6>6;?D4!7D8MM6>4b!1AR!@A67!A;6!<:8;!7AG6!@6<>66!AF!G:7?6>4!AP6>!D:;<E:<6!?=:?! :MM6:>7!?A!36!:G38<EAE7!:;@!6DE78P6b!! '=6!:37?>:9?8A;!AF!@AG67?89!A3_69?7!8;!1:<E6!/:;<`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j:!?:7U!?=:?!9:;!=:P6!;A!>67ADP6S!3E?!87!@67?8;6@!?A! >6G:8;!:!HE67?8A;!?=:?!R8DD!9A;?8;E6!?A!>6MA76!:;@!>678?E:?6!8?76DF!A;?A!:!@879E>78P6! 9A;?8;EEGT!!(!6;@!R8?=!:!HEA?6!F>AG!=6>V!c'=6!R>8?8;<!AF!9AGGE;8?4S!67M698:DD4! R=6;!GA38D8a6@!34!:!7?>:?6<4!AF!9>8?89:D!>6P878A;S!87!:!?:7U!AF!>6?>86P8;<!:;@! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ZK !&=:;?:D!,AEFF6S!c06GA9>:?89!&8?8a6;7=8M!:;@!?=6!-AD8?89:D!&AGGE;8?4Sd!8;! @#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,S!6@T!'=6!,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V! 2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87!->677S!L[[LhT! ! YY! E;>:P6D8;<!DAA76!6;@7S!A;6`7!AR;!:7!R6DD!:7!?=6!GED?8MD6!:;@!AF?6;!9A;?>:@89?A>4! 78<;8F89:?8A;7!9A;_A8;6@!A>!>69ADD69?6@!34!?=87!9ADD69?8P6!78<;8F86>Td ZL ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ZL !%8;@:!+8;<6>S!c"69:DD8;<!:!&AGGE;8?4!:?!%AA76!#;@7Sd!8;!@#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,S! 6@T!'=6!,8:G8!'=6A>4!&ADD69?8P6!f,8;;6:MAD87g)QFA>@V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;6:MAD87! ->677S!L[[Lh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c0A\1A!+E=V!+AG6g);6Sd!N=8?;64!,E76EG!AF!.G6>89:;!.>?S!*6R! /A>US!2+.S!JKKL! ! YX! ! $8<E>6!ZT!1:6<E6!/:;<S!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,R-/'$,+#*-75$'895O!JKK^! ID:9U!!:DEG8;EG!C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7S!FDAA>!D:GMS!7MA?D8<=?S!=EG8@8F86>S!8;F>:>6@!=6:?6>7S! 8;@E7?>8:D!FDAA>!F:;S!796;?MAM!G:9=8;67S!GA?8A;!76;7A>S!9:3D6! +8?6\7M698F89!8;7?:DD:?8A;S!@8G6;78A;7!P:>8:3D6! (;7?:DD:?8A;!P86R!:?!I.BS!3:787!PAA>!:9?E6D6!BE;7?S!2?>69=?S!*6?=6>D:;@7! -=A?AV!#>;7?!,A>8?a! ! ! ! YW! ! $8<E>6!]T!1:6<E6!/:;<S!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,R-:'1$*+*4-;'"1*89#"<-='>S! JKKW! +=8;4!R=8?6!:;@!F:EQ!RAA@!:DEG8;EG!C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7S!G8>>A>S!GAP8;<!7MA?D8<=?7S! 8;F>:>6@!=6:?6>7S!F:;7S!@>EG!U8?S!?>8<<6>S!,(0(!9A;P6>?6>S!9:3D6! +8?6\7M698F89!8;7?:DD:?8A;S!@8G6;78A;7!P:>8:3D6! (;7?:DD:?8A;!P86RS!c.74GG6?>89!#HE:D8?4Sd!"#0&.'S!%A7!.;<6D67S!2+.S!JKKW! &AE>?674!O:D6>86!I:>3:>:!N86;S!I6>D8;S!O6>G:;4! -=A?AV!+9A??!O>ADD6>! ! ! Y[! ! $8<E>6!^T!1:6<E6!/:;<S!%'$+',-#.-/0"*'$12"'-3$$1*4'&'*5,R-/#+8'-1*>-?+*>S!JKK[! .DEG8;EG!F>:G6S!:DEG8;G!C6;6?8:;!3D8;@7S!8;@E7?>8:D!6D69?>89!F:;7S!796;?!6G8??6>7! +8?6\7M698F89!8;7?:DD:?8A;S!@8G6;78A;7!P:>8:3D6! (;7?:DD:?8A;!P86RS!c&A;@6;7:?8A;V!1:6<E6!/:;<Sd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i!l8;!&A;_E;9?8A;!R8?=!?=6! #Q=838?8A;!p1:6<E6!/:;<V!2;6P6;D4p!:?!I.BS!I:787!CAA>!.9?E6D6!BE;7?!8;!2?>69=?S!?=6! *6?=6>D:;@7!0E>8;<!?=6!-6>8A@!F>AG!JY!.M>8D!JKK^!'8DD!LW!5E;6!JKK^mT!2?>69=?V!I.BS! I:787!PAA>!:9?E6D6!UE;7?S!JKKXT!! ! $>:;a6;S!I>8<8??6S!B:7M6>!Bq;8<S!:;@!&:>8;:!-D:?=T!%80"C50$'-H$#I'85,-;0'*,5'$-JKL- ]^K\J_\-R-`J\Ja\DJJKbT!BqD;V!Bq;8<S!JKKXT! ! 1:36>G:7S!5E><6;T!E9'-%5$0850$1"-E$1*,.#$&15+#*-#.-59'-H02"+8-%C9'$'L-3*-F*P0+$<- +*5#-1-@15'4#$<-#.-V#0$4'#+,-%#8+'5<T!&:G3>8@<6V!,('!->677S!L[[LT! ! 1:>@?S!,89=:6DS!:;@!.;?A;8A!*6<>8T!;0"5+50>'L-?1$-1*>-T'&#8$18<-+*-59'-34'-#.- B&C+$'T!*6R!/A>UV!'=6!-6;<E8;!->677S!JKKZT! ! 16<6DS!OTNT$T!H9+"#,#C9<-#.-=+495S!#@8?6@!34!'T,T!B;AQT!%A;@A;V!)QFA>@!2;8P6>78?4! ->677S!L[^XT! 1A3367S!'=AG:7T!A'G+1591*\!&:G3>8@<6V!&:G3>8@<6!2;8P6>78?4!->677S!L[[XT! (46>S!%:>7!c)E>!"67MA;7838D8?4V!ID:;9=A?`7!&AGGE;87GSd!@#*5$'&C,-D!f,:4!JKKLhS! =??MVggRRRTE74@T6@ET:Eg9A;?>6GM7gJG:4JKKLg846>TM@F!f:996776@!LJ!,:>9=! JKLKh! ! B67?6>S!O>:;?!1T!@#*G'$,15+#*-H+'8',L-@#&&0*+5<-1*>-@#&&0*+815+#*-+*-;#>'$*-3$5T! I6>U6D64V!2;8P6>78?4!AF!&:D8FA>;8:!->677S!JKKZT! ! BRA;S!,8RA;T!)*'-H"18'-3.5'$-3*#59'$L-%+5'R%C'8+.+8-3$5-1*>-A#815+#*1"-F>'*5+5<T! &:G3>8@<6S!,:77V!,('!->677S!JKKJT! ! ! ZL! *:;94S!56:;\%E9T!E9'-F*#C'$15+G'-@#&&0*+5<T!#@8?6@!34!-6?6>!&A;;6>T!,8;;6:MAD87V! 2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;67A?:!->677S!L[[LT! ! "AE776:ES!56:;\5:9HE67T!E9'-%#8+1"-@#*5$185\-1:>GA;@7RA>?=V!'=6!-6;<E8;!->677S! L[^WT! p+9EDM?E>6!&=89:<A!187?A>4!:;@!->676;?!->A<>:GSd!E;@:?6@!M>677!>6D6:76S!;TMT! C:;!06;!.3366D6S!O6A><67S!:;@!A?=6>7S!6@7T!@#&&0*+5<-15-A##,'-B*>,\!,8;;6:MAD87V! 2;8P6>78?4!AF!,8;;67A?:!->677S!L[[LT! ! C8@D6>S!.;?=A;4T!?1$C'>-%C18'L-3$5O-3$89+5'850$'O-1*>-3*[+'5<-+*-;#>'$*-@0"50$'T! &:G3>8@<6V!,('!->677S!JKKKT! ! ! ! !

Abstract (if available)

Linked assets

University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses

Conceptually similar

PDF

Contemporary art and "post-black" identity politics

PDF

Art and time: temporary public art and contentious space

PDF

Interpreting participatory art

PDF

Cultivating the arts in rural communities of the San Joaquin valley

PDF

In the art of revolution: integrating community arts into the existing development work of non-government organizations in Guatemala and El Salvador

PDF

Biennial rising: Prospect.1 New Orleans and the post-disaster arts movement

PDF

The kinesthetic citizen: Dance and critical art practices

PDF

Art and cultural diplomacy in the international exhibition: documenta 1 and Prospect.1

PDF

Community engaged art: no longer a form of resistance?

PDF

Public art in Houston: administrative structure analysis and artist guidebook

PDF

Reconsideration of permanent percent for art works in the public sphere: a case study of public art commissioned by the community redevelopment agency of the city of Los Angeles

PDF

Making art public: mobilizing public art through technology

PDF

Allen Ruppersberg: Art on the edge of visibility, 1968–1972

PDF

Coastal public art: an innovative way to disseminate ocean science

PDF

Collaborative art practice in the public sphere: The death of the artist?

PDF

(M)other work: feminist maternal performance art

PDF

Mejor vida/better life and day-to-day exchanges: Networks of social exchange in contemporary arts practice

PDF

Tracing a history: an exploration of contemporary Chicano art and artists

PDF

Fostering vital places: public art and the revitalization of the Los Angeles River

PDF

Temporary or permanent? Considering time, memory and history in public art projects

Asset Metadata

Creator Yang, Jessica (author)

Core Title Reflections on contemporary art and the rhetoric of community

School School of Fine Arts

Degree Master of Public Art Studies

Degree Program Public Art Studies

Publication Date 05/11/2011

Defense Date 05/01/2011

Publisher University of Southern California (original), University of Southern California. Libraries (digital)

Tag art,Community,do ho suh,hague yang,Jean-Luc Nancy,OAI-PMH Harvest,public art

Language English

Contributor Electronically uploaded by the author (provenance)

Advisor Bray, Anne (committee chair), Siddiqui, Yasmeen (committee chair), Decter, Joshua (committee member)

Creator Email jessicahyang@gmail.com,jessichy@usc.edu

Permanent Link (DOI) https://doi.org/10.25549/usctheses-m3940

Unique identifier UC1471921

Identifier etd-Yang-4516 (filename),usctheses-m40 (legacy collection record id),usctheses-c127-475989 (legacy record id),usctheses-m3940 (legacy record id)

Legacy Identifier etd-Yang-4516.pdf

Dmrecord 475989

Document Type Thesis

Rights Yang, Jessica

Type texts

Source University of Southern California (contributing entity), University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses (collection)

Repository Name Libraries, University of Southern California

Repository Location Los Angeles, California

Repository Email cisadmin@lib.usc.edu