Close
The page header's logo
About
FAQ
Home
Collections
Login
USC Login
Register
0
Selected 
Invert selection
Deselect all
Deselect all
 Click here to refresh results
 Click here to refresh results
USC
/
Digital Library
/
University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses
/
Fighting old‐time slavery in modern‐day L.A.
(USC Thesis Other) 

Fighting old‐time slavery in modern‐day L.A.

doctype icon
play button
PDF
 Download
 Share
 Open document
 Flip pages
 More
 Download a page range
 Download transcript
Copy asset link
Request this asset
Transcript (if available)
Content FIGHTING
OLD‐TIME
SLAVERY
IN
MODERN‐DAY
L.A.
 
 
 by
 
 Daysha
Eaton
 
 
 
 A
Professional
Project
Presented
to
the

 FACULTY
OF
THE
GRADUATE
SCHOOL
 UNIVERSITY
OF
SOUTHERN
CALIFORNIA

 In
Partial
Fulfillment
of
the

 Requirements
for
the
Degree
 MASTER
OF
ARTS

 (SPECIALIZED
JOURNALISM)
 
 
 December
2009
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Copyright
2009
 
 
 
 
 
 
 Daysha
Eaton
 
 
 
 ii
 
 Table
of
Contents
 
 Abstract
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 iii
 Host
Introduction
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 1
 Fighting
Old‐Time
Slavery
in
Modern‐Day
L.A.
 
 
 
 2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 iii
 Abstract
 
 Although
immigration
experts
say
unauthorized
flows
across
the
Southern
 border
have
dropped
in
the
current
recession,
United
Nations
officials
worry
 that
the
global
economic
recession
will
create
more
and
more
victims
of
 human
trafficking.
The
State
Department
estimates
that
up
to
17‐thousand
 people
are
trafficked
into
the
U‐S
each
year
–
many
via
the
Southern
border.
 They
say
about
three
quarters
of
them
are
women
and
half
are
minors.
 Activists
say
human
trafficking
is
modern
day
slavery
–
and
they
say
it’s
 having
a
serious
impact
on
immigrants.
In
2000
Congress
passed
the
 Trafficking
Victims
Protection
Act,
which
made
human
trafficking
illegal
in
 the
United
States.
Since
2005
Police
and
anti‐trafficking
activists
have
 discovered
more
than
200
victims
in
L‐A.
But
they
say
there
are
likely
 hundreds
more
that
go
unaccounted
for.
A
growing
number
of
activists
scour
 the
streets
of
L‐A
every
day,
in
search
of
people
are
still
being
forced
to
work
 for
no
pay.
They
are,
in
essence,
modern‐day
abolitionists.
This
radio
 documentary
tells
their
story.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 1
 Host
Introduction
 
 Since
the
turn
of
the
21 st 
century,
a
movement
to
fight
modern‐day
slavery
 has
been
growing.
One
of
the
places
where
it
has
taken
root
is
Los
Angeles,
a
 destination
and
transit
city
for
human
trafficking.
The
new
abolitionists
say
 their
cause
is
rooted
in
the
abolition
movement
of
the
19 th 
century.
But
 rather
than
standing
up
for
black
African
slaves,
today’s
abolitionists
are
 fighting
for
the
rights
of
immigrants
from
South
Asia,
Central
America
and
 Mexico
who
are
often
led
to
the
U.S.
on
false
promises
of
legitimate
 employment
and
then
forced
to
work
for
little
or
no
pay,
sometimes
in
 abusive
situations.

Although
the
new
abolitionists
have
good
intentions,
 their
efforts
often
seem
futile
in
the
face
of
laws
that
do
not
adequately
 address
this
complex
crime.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 2
 Fighting
Old‐Time
Slavery
In
Modern‐Day
L.A.
 
 RUBEN
NUNO
KNOWS
THEY’RE
HERE,
BUT
THEY’RE
VERY
HARD
TO
FIND.
 
“We
go
and
speak
with
people,
go
to
areas
that
might
have
 large
concentrations
of
undocumented
workers.”
 LIKE
THE
GARMENT
DISTRICT,
IN
DOWNTOWN
LOS
ANGELES.

 
 
 <<nats
horns
street>>
 NUNO
SPENDS
A
LOT
OF
TIME
HERE
…
HE
HEADS
UP
THE
SALVATION
 ARMY’S
HUMAN
TRAFFICKING
DIVISION
IN
L‐A.
 <<nats:
Collage
of
sounds
from
street>>
 
TALL
MANUFACTURING
BUILDINGS
LINE
THE
STREETS
…
RUNDOWN
 SWEATSHOPS
SIDE‐BY‐SIDE
WITH
REMODELLED
LOFTS
…
 <<nat
pop
from
Ruben
“We’re
just
gonna
go
see
if
we
can
 find
some
people
on
their
lunchbreaks.>>


 THE
ANTI‐TRAFFICKING
MOVEMENT
GOT
OFF
THE
GROUND
IN
LOS
 ANGELES
IN
1995,
WITH
THE
INFAMOUS
EL
MONTE
SWEAT
SHOP
BUST.
 THAT’S
WHEN
AUTHORITIES
UNCOVERED
MORE
THAN
70
THAI
 TRAFFICKING
VICTIMS
FORCED
TO
SEW
CLOTHES
IN
SLAVERY‐LIKE
 CONDITIONS
FOR
MORE
THAN
*EIGHT
YEARS.
 1 
IT
PUT
THE
ISSUE
OF
 























































 1 
Aug
2005,
http://articles.latimes.com/2005/aug/02/opinion/oe‐scheer2,
 May
2009.
 
 
 
 3
 TRAFFICKING
ON
THE
MAP.
EVERYONE
WAS
SHOCKED
THAT
IT
WAS
 ACTUALLY
HAPPENING
RIGHT
HERE
IN
THE
U‐S. 
 
 <<Nat
pop
from
Ruben>>
 AS
WE
WALK
PAST
STOREFONTS
…
SELLING
EVERTYTHING
FROM
CD’S
 AND
CELL

PHONES
TO
PARAKEETS
…
STREET
VENDERS
WEAVE
THROUGH
 CROWDS
RINGING
BELLS.
 
 <<Nats
street
noise
to
music
to
parakeets
to
bells
nats>>
 “It’s
very
gritty.
We
have
a
mixture
of
Spanish
signs
and
 old
historic
signs.
You
have
the
Orpheum
and
you
have
 Julio’s
tacos
next
to
each
other.
People
eating
on
the
side
 and
selling
telephones.
It
kind
of
shows
you
where
it
was
 and
where
it’s
going.
You
can
sense
that
there’s
a
lot
going
 on.
Whenever
I
walk
I
see
these
high
rise
buildings
and
I
 think,
‘what’s
going
on
inside
them?”
 THIS
IS
A
QUESTION
THAT
BRINGS
NUNO
TO
THE
GARMENT
DISTRICT
 OFTEN.
HE
SPENDS
A
LOT
OF
HIS
TIME
DOING
WHAT
HE
CALLS,
 ‘OUTREACH.’
 “We’re
just
goona
go
see
if
we
can
find
some
people
on
 their
lunch
breaks.
The
more
we
talk
to
people,
the
more
 we
build
relationships,
the
more
they
may
open
up.
 NUNO
BLENDS
IN.
HE’S
TRADED
IN
HIS
OFFICE
CLOTHES
FOR
A
 GUAYABERA
SHIRT
AND
A
WOOL
CAP.
WE
CHECK
OUT
A
PLACE
NUNO
HAS
 A
TIP
ABOUT.

 
 
 
 
 4
 <<Nats:
going
up
stairs>>
Ruben
says:‘Salvation
Army’
 then
sewing
sounds
come
up
…
whistling
.
..
Ruben
says,
 ‘that’s
what
the
workers
were
telling
us
…
it’s
the
8 th 
floor’
 and
he
talks
about
street
venders.>>
 BUT
ALL
WE
FIND
ARE
ROWS
OF
CENTRAL
AMERICAN
WORKERS,
 SURROUNDED
BY
MOUNDS
OF
BRIGHTLY
COLORED
FABRIC,
STARING
 BACK
AT
US
FROM
THEIR
SEWING
MACHINES.
NUNO
SAYS
HE’LL
KEEP
HIS
 EYE
ON
THE
BUILDING.
 SEVERAL
MILES
WEST
IN
KOREA
TOWN
ANOTHER
DIVISION
OF
THIS
 INFORMAL
ANTITRAFFICKING
BRIGADE
IS
DOING
THEIR
OWN
SEARCH
 FOR
VICTIMS.

CHARITY
MARQUIS
‐‐
A
FORMAL
MODEL
TURENED
SEX
 TRAFFICKING
ACTIVIST
‐‐
IS
THE
LEADER.

 “This
is
our
opportunity
to
engage
the
city
on
this
issue.”
 MARQUIS
WORKS
FOR
NIGHT
LIGHT,
A
NON‐PROFIT
ORGANIZATION
THAT
 SPECIFICALLY
FOCUSES
ON
STOPPING
SEX
TRAFFICKING.
IN
THE
SHADOW
 OF
EMPTY
OFFICE
TOWERS
SHE
GATHERS
THE
GROUP
OF
ABOUT
A
DOZEN
 ACTIVISTS
AT
THE
METRO
STOP
TO
SAY
A
PRAYER
BEFORE
HEADING
OUT.
 “Okay
it’s
8:29
–
so
let’s
meet
back
here
at
9:30
and
we’ve
 never
hit
this
end
–
we’re
really
between
MacArthur
Park
 and
Korea
Town.
There
are
quite
a
few
businesses.
I’ll
pray
 and
then
we’ll
split
up.
Praying.”
 MARIQUIS,
A
SIX‐FOOT
TALL
BOTTLE
BLOND
WHO
IS
SIX
MONTHES
 PREGNANT,
PEEKS
HER
HEAD
INTO
A
CONVENIENCE
STORE,
A
BEAUTY
 PARLOR
…
A
NIGHTCLUB
…
 
 
 
 5
 “You
drop
these
brochures
and
these
posters
and
you
 never
know
when
someone’s
goona
walk
by
and
grab
it
 and
what
they’re
goona
do
with
that
information.
And
you
 don’t
even
notice
these
places
until
you
got
out
of
your
car
 and
walk
around.”
 BUT
SHE
ISN’T
HAVING
MUCH
LUCK
FINDING
VICTIMS
EITHER,
AND
SHE
 HAS
TO
BE
CONTENT
HANDING
OUT
BROCHURES.
 
“Some
nights
it’s
not
very
eventful.
Some
nights
we
come
 back
with
amazing
stories
of
conversations
that
we
had
or
 something
that
somebody
shared
with
us
about
what
they
 know
is
going
on.”
 
 MARQUIS
IS
ABOUT
TO
CALL
IT
A
NIGHT,
WHEN
SUDDENLY
A
SHABILY
 DRESSED
LATINO
MAN
COMES
UP
AND
WHISPERS
THAT
HE
HAS
 INFORMATION
SHE
SHOULD
KNOW
ABOUT
BUT
HE
CAN’T
TALK
NOW
...
 SHE
HANDS
HIM
A
TRAFFICKING
BROCHURE
WITH
A
1‐800
NUMBER
 WHERE
HE
CAN
REPORT
WHAT
HE
KNOWS
ANONYMOUSLY.
HE’S
SHIFTY
 AND
JUST
AS
QUICKLY
AS
HE
APPEARED,
HE’S
GONE
.
 “He
said
that
he
knows
of
a
location
and
had
some
phone
 numbers
but
then
he
started
to
get
really
nervous,
really
 uncomfortable
…
he
was
concerned
that
maybe
he
was
 being
watched.
This
area
is
controlled
by
gang
members.
 We’re
hoping
that
we’ll
be
able
to
connect
with
him
again
 and
get
the
information
that
he
has.”

 MARQUIS
NEVER
CONNECTED
WITH
THE
MAN.
HER
ONLY
HOPE
IS
THAT
 HE
CALLED
THE
TRAFFICKING
HOTLINE
TO
LEAVE
A
TIP.
 THERE
ARE
DOZENS
OF
PEOPLE
LIKE
MARQUIS
AND
NUNO
ALL
OVER
L‐A,
 SEARCHING
THE
STREETS
AND
MONITORING
HOTLINES.
A
RECENT
 
 
 
 6
 REPORT
FROM
THE
UNITED
NATIONS

SAYS
MOST
OF
THE
TRAFFICKING
 VICTIMS
THEIR
LOOKING
FOR
COME
FROM
THAILAND,
MEXICO
AND
 GUATEMALA. 2 
 ANTONIO
MARIA
COSTA
HEADS
UP
THE
UNITED
NATIONS
OFFICE
OF
 DRUGS
AND
CRIME,
DID
THE
REPORT.
HE
SAYS
PEOPLE
LIKE
NUNO
AND
 MARQUIS
ARE
PART
OF
A
GROWING
GLOBAL
MOVEMENT
TO
FIGHT
 TRAFFICKING.

 “It’s
definitely
growing,
because
of
the
rising
global
 awareness
being
built
by
the
united
nations
legislation,
by
 the
motivation
at
the
national
level,
by
the
courageous
 effort
of
ngo’s,
religious
groups.
All
of
this
of
course
seems
 to
be
introducing,
let
us
say
­­


a
culture
on
the
individual
 level
that
the
problem
has
to
be
fought.”
 AT
THE
SAME
TIME
AWARENESS
IS
GROWING,
COSTA
SAYS
TRAFFICKING
 IS
LIKELY
TO
SPIKE
DUE
TO
THE
ECONOMIC
DOWNTURN.
 “When
there
are
economic
and
social
hardships,
especially
 the
size
and
spread
of
today,
inevitably
this
sort
of
crime
 tends
to
become
more
serious
both
driven
by
demand
and
 by
supply.
More
people
more
vulnerable
than
in
the
past
–
 because
of
having
lost
a
job,
having
lost
a
source
of
income,
 having
a
house.
And
on
the
demand
side
you
have
 consumers
trying
to
cut
costs
or
reduce
the
price
of
the
 commodities
they
or
service
they
buy.”
 AND
COSTA
CAUTIONS
AGAINST
THE
IDEA
THAT
NON‐PROFITS
OR
 RELIGIOUS
ORGANISATIONS
LIKE
THE
SALVATION
ARMY
CAN
STOP
 























































 2 
Feb.
2009,
http://www.unodc.org/documents/Global_Report_on_TIP.pdf,
 May
2009.
 
 
 
 7
 TRAFFICKING
ALONE.
HE
SAYS
THAT’S
BECAUSE
OF
ALL
THE
CRIMES
THAT
 HIS
OFFICE
WORKS
ON
HUMAN
TRAFFICKING
IS
THE
MOST
DIFFICULT.
 “I
believe
that
the
crime
of
human
trafficking
is
probably
 the
most
complex
to
identify,
to
work
with
and
to
fight
 because
it
overlaps
with
so
many
other
areas.
…

 AND
IT’S
A
CRIME
THE
LOS
ANGELES
POLICE
DEPARTMENT
DEALS
WITH
 TOO.
 “Robbery
Homicide,
Kimberly,
may
I
help
you?
Hold
on
 one
second.

 THAT’S
KIMBERLY
AGBONKPOLAR.
SHE
HEADS
UP
THE
ANTI‐TRAFFICKING
 TASK
FORCE
FOR
THE
L‐A‐P‐D.
THIS
MORNING
AGBONKPOLAR
IS
ON
THE
 PHONE
WITH
A
NON
PROFIT
ORGANIZATION
THAT
HELPS
TRAFFICKING
 VICTIMS.
HER
OFFICERS
FOUND
A
VICTIM
OVERNIGHT.

RIGHT
NOW
U‐S
 IMMIGRATION
AND
CUSTOMS
EFORCEMENT
OR
ICE
IS
INTERVIEWING
 HER.
THAT’S
WHAT
HAPPENS
WHEN
A
TRAFFICKING
VICTIM
IS
AN
 UNDOCUMENTED
IMMIGRANT.
THE
KEY
TO
THE
VICTIM
GETTING
HELP
IS
 PROVING
THEY
WERE
FORCED
INTO
THE
SITUATION.
IN
THIS
WOMAN’S
 CASE
SHE
SAYS
SHE
WAS
KIDNAPPED.
 
“She
was
abducted
…
um
brought
her
on
a
boat
and
 another
way.
They
gave
her
some
false
documents
to
cross
 immigration.
From
her
story
I
guess
they
took
a
whole
 bunch
of
girls,
not
just
her.
How
many?”
 THROUGH
AN
INTERPRETER
THEY’VE
LEARNED
THE
19‐YEAR‐OLD
SAYS
 SHE
IS
A
UNIVERSITY
STUDENT
FROM
MEXICO.

 
 
 
 8
 
“From
what
she’s
saying
a
lot
of
the
girls
were
taken
–
they
 were
crying
and
scared
and
I
guess
as
they
came
into
this
 house
they
picked
and
choosed
who
would
work,
who
 couldn’t
work
an
they
just
kinda
sent
her
on
her
way.”
 THE
POLICE
FOUND
HER,
BAREFOOT
IN
DOWNTOWN
L.A.
IN
THE
POURING
 RAIN
AGBONKPOLAR
SAYS
ITS
LIKELY
A
PROSTITUTION
RING.

 <<Home
Depot
Parking
Lot
Nats>>

 IN
RECENT
WEEKS
NUNO
HAS
BROADENED
HIS
SEARCH
BEYOND
THE
 DOWNTOWN
SWEATSHOPS
TO
THE
PARKING
LOTS
OF
PLACES
LIKE
THE
 HOME
DEPOT
HERE
AT
THE
CORNER
OF
WILSHIRE
AND
UNION
IN
THE
 HEART
OF
LOS
ANGELES’S
CENTRAL
AMERICAN
NEIGHOBORHOOD.
THAT’S
 WHERE
HE
MET
JAVIER.
HE
SAYS
HE
WAS
TRICKED
BY
A
TRAFFICKER
INTO
 SIGNING
OVER
HIS
LAND
BACK
IN
GUATEMALA
IN
ORDER
TO
PAY
FOR
 TRANSPORT
TO
THE
U‐S.
 
(Javier)
“Imagínese
el
tiempo
que
estamos,
eh,
a
veces
nos
 desesperamos,
nos
queremos
ir
para
nuestro
país
pero
 con
esa
deuda
tenemos,
¿a
dónde
vamos
a
ir
a
dar?
Si
nos
 quitan
la
casa,
¿a
dónde
vamos
a
ir
a
vivir?

 
(Voiceover)
“SOMETIMES
WE
GET
REALLY
DESPERATE
 AND
WE
WANT
TO
GO
BACK
TO
OUR
COUNTRY
BUT
WITH
 THIS
DEBT
THAT
WE
HAVE,
WHERE
ARE
WE
GOING
TO
 GO?
IF
THEY
TAKE
OUR
HOUSES
AWAY,
WHERE
ARE
WE
 GOING
TO
LIVE?”
 JAVIER
SIGNED
OVER
THE
DEED
TO
HIS
HOME
IN
MAZATENAGO
SUCH,
 GUATEMALA
AS
COLLATORAL
FOR
A
LOAN
TO
PAY
A
SMUGGLING
FEE.
THE
 LOAN
HAD
A
VERY
HIGH
INTEREST
RATE.
THE
LENDER,
WHO
HE
SAYS
IS
 
 
 
 9
 CONNECTED
TO
THE
TRAFFICKER,
IS
THREATING
TO
TAKE
HIS
HOME
AND
 KILL
HIS
FAMILY.
DESPERATE
FOR
HELP
WITH
HIS
SPIRALLING
SITUATION
 JAVIER
OPENED
UP
TO
RUBEN.
 (Javier)
“Oh,
son
miles
de
personas
que
él
ha
traído
para
 acá.
Um,
miles.”<<butt
with>>
 “S:
Por
lo
que
he
visto
orita
son
tres
personas
que
él
le
ha
 embargado
ya
el
terreno.”
 
(Voiceover)
“OH
IT’S
THOUSANDS
OF
PEOPLE
THAT
HE
 HAS
BROUGHT
HERE.
THOUSANDS.
FOR
WHAT
I
KNOW,
 IT’S
THREE
PERSONS
THAT
HE
HAS
TAKEN
THEIR
LAND
 AWAY.”
 ONCE
RUBEN
BEGAN
TALKING
WITH
JAVIER
OTHER
MEN
CAME
FORWARD,
 LIKE
MANUEL
WHO
IS
IN
THE
SAME
SITUATION
‐‐BUT
HE
CAME
TO
L‐A
 THREE
YEARS
AGO
FROM
RURAL
SOLOLA,
GUATAMLA
‐‐
AND
THE
 INTEREST
ON
HIS
LOAN
IS
EVEN
HIGHER
‐‐
20
PERCENT.
MANUEL
IS
 INDIGINOUS
MAYA
INDIAN.
HE
SPEAKS
QUICHE
AND
WHAT
SPANISH
HE
 KNOWS
HE
LEARNED
IN
CALIFORNIA.
 
(Manuel
fades
under)
“Uh,
como
tiena,
hay,
no,
no,
no
mira
 coyote,
sólo
engachador.
Y
después
ya
llegó
a
mi
casa
y
 dice
”Vamos
Manuel,
allá,
hay,
hay
dinero,
¿no
quiere
 diner,
dólares?,
¿por
cientes?.
Allí,
allá
muchos
dólares“
 
(Voiceover)
“I
DIDN’T
MEET
THE
TRAFFICKER,
ONLY
HIS
 CONTACT.
AND
THEN
HE
CAME
TO
MY
HOUSE
AND
SAID,
 “COME
MANUEL,
THERE
IS
MONEY
OVER
THERE.
DON’T
 YOU
WANT
MONEY?
DOLLARS?
BY
THE
HUNDREDS?
 THERE
IS
LOT
OF
DOLLARS
OVER
THERE.”
 
 
 
 10
 MANUEL
SAYS
–
DESPERATE
TO
SUPPORT
HIS
FAMILY,
HE
SIGNED
OVER
 THE
DEED
TO
HIS
HOUSE
TOO
AND
SIGNED
THE
CONTRACT,
WHICH
WAS
 WRTITEN
IN
SPANISH
WITH
THE
ONLY
THING
HE
CAN
WRITE
–
HIS
NAME.

 NOW
HE
LIVES
IN
A
SQUALID,
ONE
ROOM
APARTMENT
HE
SHARES
WITH
 FIVE
OTHER
MEN
JUST
A
FEW
BLOCKS
FROM
THE
HOME
DEPOT
WHERE
 THEY
SPEND
THEIR
DAYS
TRYING
TO
WAVE
DOWN
DRIVERS
TO
FIND
ODD
 JOBS.
 
(Ruben)“Yeah,
he’s
in
bad
situation.”
 LATELY
MANUEL
SAYS
HE’S
ONLY
BEEN
ABLE
TO
SEND
HOME
ABOUT
A
 HUNDRED
DOLLARS
A
WEEK
AND
IT’S
JUST
NOT
ENOUGH.

 
(Ruben)The
trafficker
called
him
yesterday
and
says,
‘
you
 owe
me
82,000
quexales
...
which
is
probably
around
 $9,000
–
says
you
owe
me
$9,000
in
interest,
and
its
better
 for
you
to
come
back
here
to
Guatemala
because
I’m
goona
 kill
your
family.
 AFTER
OUR
INTERVIEW
MANUEL
RECEIVED
NEWS
FROM
HIS
WIFE
THAT
 HIS
FAMILY
HAD
BEEN
EVICTED
FROM
THEIR
LAND
IN
SOLOLA.

AFTER
 YEARS
OF
SWINGING
HAMMERS,
LAYING
TILE
AND
DRYWALLING,
MEN
 LIKE
JAVIER
AND
MANUEL
ARE
CAUGHT
BETWEEN
TWO
VERY
DIFFICULT
 EXISTANCES.
IF
THEY
RETURN
TO
GUATEMALA,
THEY
FACE
HOMELESS
 AND
POSSIBLE
DEATH.
IF
THEY
REMAIN
IN
THE
U‐S
ILLEGIALLY,
THEY
 MUST
ENDURE
THE
RECESSION
AND
MAY
LOSE
THEIR
HOMES
ANYWAY.
 
 
 
 11
 “There’s
a
massive,
massive
demographic
of
mainly
 Guatemalan
males
that
are
here
in
a
form
of
debt
 bondage.”
 BUT
IMMIGRATION
AUTHORITIES
SEE
IT
DIFFERENTLY.
BECAUSE
JAVIER
 AND
MANUEL
DECIDED
TO
COME
TO
THE
U‐S
OF
THEIR
OWN
VOLITION
–
 EVEN
IF
THEY
WERE
TRICKED
–
THEIR
CASES
DO
NOT
MEET
THE
FEDERAL
 REQUIREMENT
OF
FORCE
NECESSARY
TO
HELP
THEM
OUT
OF
THEIR
 SITUATION.
IF
RUBEN
DELIVERS
THEM
TO
ICE,
THEY
WILL
JUST
BE
 DEPORTED.
 
“And
I
think
the
unfortunate
thing
is
that
these
guys
are
 preyed
upon
by
guys
who,
you
know,
realize
that
they
 don’t
know
how
to
read
and
write
and
work
well
with
 numbers.
You
know
these
guys
are
farmers
you
know
they
 know
how
to
work
with
the
land,
they
know
how
to
work
 with
the
hammer
and
this
may
be
what
a
lot
of
debt
 bondage
in
America
looks
like.
They’re
right
her
under
our
 noses
–
you
know
they’re
right
there,
standing
on
the
 corner
waiting
for
somebody
to
pick
them
up
and
give
 them
some
work.”
 BUT
THE
LAW
CAN’T
HELP
JAVIER
AND
MANUEL
BECAUSE
THEY
DON’T
 QUITE
FIT
THE
AMERICAN
DEFINITION
OF
HUMAN
TRAFFICKING.
AS
OF
 YET,
THERE
IS
NO
UNIVERSALLY
AGREED
UPON
DEFINITION.
BUT
 ACCORDING
TO
U‐S
LAW,
HUMAN
TRAFFICKING
IS
WHEN
ONE
PERSON
 FORCES
ANOTHER
TO
WORK
FOR
NO
PAY
BY
MEANS
OF
FORCE,
FRAUD
OR
 
 
 
 12
 COERSION. 3 
CHARLES
SONG,
A
PROMINENT
IMMIGRATION
ATTORENY
IN
 LOS
ANGLELES
EXPLAINS.
 “The
UN’s
definition
focuses
on
exploitation
and
not
purely
 force,
whereas
the
U­S
definition
really
derives
from
our
 definitions
of
slavery.
I
think
that’s
what
makes
it
a
little
 bit
overly
restrictive.”
 SONG
SAYS
THE
PROBLEM
WITH
OUR
TRAFFICKING
LAW
IS
THAT
IT
IS
 BASED
ON
LEGISLATION
THAT
WAS
CREATED
TO
ADDRESS
THE
 SITUATIONS
AFRICAN
SLAVES
WOULD
HAVE
ENCOUNTRED
IN
THE
1800’S
‐ ‐
NOT
TO
ADDRESS
ISSUES
OF
21 ST 
CENTURY
MIGRATION.

BUT
SONG
SAYS
 A
LONG‐TERM
SOLLUTION
TO
TRAFFICKING
MUST
ADDRESS
DEEPER
 PROBLEMS.
 “Well
there’s
a
lot
of
talk
about
how
terrible
trafficking
 and
forced
labor
and
slavery
is
…
and
there
are
people
 always
asking
me,
‘well
what
can
we
do
about
it,
how
can
 we
help
if
Trafficking
and
slavery
is
such
a
high
priority
 for
us
an
is
such
a
terrible
thing
we
need
to
really
look
at
 the
way
our
immigration
laws
are
set
up
and
the
way
they
 are
enforced.”
 SONG
SAYS
AVOIDING
COMPREHENSIVE
IMMIGRATION
REFORM
IS
IN
 AFFECT
SUPPORTING
HUMAN
TRAFFICKING.

AND
HE
SAYS
IMMIGRATION
 ENFORCEMENT
IN
THE
FORM
OF
RAIDS
COULD
ACTUALLY
STRENGTHEN
 THE
HANDS
OF
THE
TRAFFICKERS.
IN
SOME
CASES
HE
SAYS
HE’S
SEEN
 SLAVEHOLDERS
THREATEN
THE
VICTIMS
INTO
SUBMISSION
BY
TELLING
 























































 3 
May
2005,
http://www.state.gov/documents/organization/33216.pdf,
May
 2009.
 
 
 
 13
 THEM
THAT
THEY
WILL
TURN
THEM
OVER
TO
IMMIGRATION
OR
THE
 POLICE
IF
THEY
DON’T
COOPERATE.
AND
HE
SAYS
THAT’S
ONE
OF
THE
 REASONS
TRAFFICKING
VICTIMS
DON’T
GO
TO
THE
POLICE
FOR
HELP
IN
 THE
FIRST
PLACE.
SONG
SAYS
THIS
FEAR
MAKES
IT
DIFFICULT
FOR
 AUTHORITIES
TO
WORK
WITH
VICTIMS
TO
PROSECUTE
CASES
…
AND
IT
 MIGHT
HAVE
SOMETHING
TO
DO
WITH
THE
LOW
CONVICTION
NUMBERS
 ON
TRAFFICKING
CASES.
SINCE
THE
U‐S
TRAFFICKING
LAW
WAS
ADOPTED
 EIGHT
YEARS
AGO,
THE
JUSTICE
DEPARTMENT
HAS
SECURED
JUST
788
 CONVICTIONS.

 BUT
SONG
SAYS
THE
SYSTEM
WE
HAVE
IN
PLACE
IS
A
START.
MEANTIME
 THE
TRAFFICKING
MOVEMENT
IS
BUILDING
…
IN
SOME
UNEXPECTED
 PLACES.
 <<nats
of
hostel
lobby,
pool>>
 LIKE
THIS
YOUTH
HOSTEL
ON
MELROSE
AVENUE.
THAT’S
WHERE
A
GROUP
 OF
YOUNG
TRAFFICKING
ACTIVISTS
ARE
CAMPED
OUT
FOR
A
WEEK
IN
L‐A.
 THEY’VE
BEEN
TRAVELLING
AROUND
THE
CITY
LEARNING
ABOUT
SOCIAL
 ISSUES,
INCLUDING
TRAFFICKING.
 <<nats
from
kids:
“we
went
here
and
there.”
 THESE
KIDS
ARE
PART
OF
FACELESS
INTERNATIONAL,
A
HUMANITARIAN
 GROUP
BASED
IN
NASHVILLE,
TENESSEE
THAT
SEES
FIGHTING
HUMAN
 TRAFFICKING
AS
PART
OF
A
LARGER
MOVEMENT
TO
STOP
THE
 
 
 
 14
 EXPLOITATION
OF
PEOPLE
–
MANY
OF
WHOM
ARE
IMMIGRANTS.
CECILIA
 ALFONZO
CAME
ALL
THE
WAY
TO
L‐A
FROM
GREENVILLE
NORTH
 CAROLINA.
WHILE
IN
L‐A
SHE
VISITED
A
SHELTER
FOR
TRAFFICKING
 VICTIMS
AND
SAW
A
FILM
ABOUT
SEX
TRAFFICKING.
 “It
ended
with
her
looking
out
the
window
of
the
bedroom
 that
she
had
just
been
raped
in
and
she
saw
an
American
 flag
and
she
was
in
the
midst
of
this
big
city
and
she
 realized
she
was
in
America.”
 THE
KIDS
SAY
THE
TRIP
MADE
AN
IMPRESSION
ON
THEM.
 (reporter:
“And
how
do
you
guys
feel
…
do
you
feel
like
 you’re
goona
go
back
and
start
something
where
you’re
 from?
)
Heck
yeah!
Five
minutes
after
…
I
updated
my
 facebook
status
from
my
phone
and
I
was
like
I’m
goona
go
 home
and
give
presentations
cause
that
was
amazing.”
 21‐YEAR‐OLD
ANDREW
BEEKLER,
FROM
MINNEAPOLIS,
SAYS
THE
TRIP
 CHANGED
HIS
PERSPECTIVE.
 “I’ve
always
known
that
human
trafficking
exists
…
but
 coming
here,
I’ve
realized
that
it
is
much
more
prevalent
 in
the
the
united
states
than
I’d
originally
thought.
You
 know
you
always
kinda
think
that
its
something
that
 happens
in
Africa
or
in
Asia
or
the
Ukraine.

 AND
HE
SAYS
IT
MADE
HIM
WANT
TO
TAKE
ACTION.
 So
being
aware
that
it’s
here,
it’s
time
that
as
youth
and
as
 the
future
of
our
country
it’s
time
for
us
to
take
a
stand
 against
it
and
demand
that
our
politicians,
the
people
that
 we
have
elected
they
know
what
we
want
done.

 WHAT
EXACTLY
POLITICIANS
WILL
DO
ABOUT
TRAFFICKING
IS
YET
TO
BE
 SEEN.
 IN
LOS
ANGELES,
I’M
DAYSHA
EATON
REPORTING. 
Asset Metadata
Creator Eaton, Daysha (author) 
Core Title Fighting old‐time slavery in modern‐day L.A. 
Contributor Electronically uploaded by the author (provenance) 
School Annenberg School for Communication 
Degree Master of Arts 
Degree Program Journalism (Broadcast Journalism) 
Degree Conferral Date 2009-12 
Publication Date 09/28/2009 
Defense Date 06/06/2009 
Publisher University of Southern California (original), University of Southern California. Libraries (digital) 
Tag American studies,Daysha Eaton,debt bondage,human trafficking,immigration,Law,Los Angeles,OAI-PMH Harvest 
Place Name Los Angeles (counties) 
Language English
Advisor Tolan, Sandy (committee chair), Banet-Weiser, Sarah (committee member), Smith, Erna (committee member) 
Creator Email dayshaea@usc.edu,dayshaeaton@gmail.com 
Permanent Link (DOI) https://doi.org/10.25549/usctheses-m2621 
Unique identifier UC1504070 
Identifier etd-Eaton-3194 (filename),usctheses-m40 (legacy collection record id),usctheses-c127-251330 (legacy record id),usctheses-m2621 (legacy record id) 
Legacy Identifier etd-Eaton-3194.pdf 
Dmrecord 251330 
Document Type Project 
Rights Eaton, Daysha 
Type texts
Source University of Southern California (contributing entity), University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses (collection) 
Repository Name Libraries, University of Southern California
Repository Location Los Angeles, California
Repository Email uscdl@usc.edu
Abstract (if available)
Abstract Although immigration experts say unauthorized flows across the Southern border have dropped in the current recession, United Nations officials worry that the global economic recession will create more and more victims of human trafficking. The State Department estimates that up to 17-thousand people are trafficked into the U-S each year – many via the Southern border. They say about three quarters of them are women and half are minors. Activists say human trafficking is modern day slavery – and they say it’s having a serious impact on immigrants. In 2000 Congress passed the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, which made human trafficking illegal in the United States. Since 2005 Police and anti-trafficking activists have discovered more than 200 victims in L-A. But they say there are likely hundreds more that go unaccounted for. A growing number of activists scour the streets of L-A every day, in search of people are still being forced to work for no pay. They are, in essence, modern-day abolitionists. This radio documentary tells their story. 
Tags
American studies
Daysha Eaton
debt bondage
human trafficking
Linked assets
University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses
doctype icon
University of Southern California Dissertations and Theses 
Action button